Dungeons & Dragons: Daggerdale

Even though almost 3 years have passed since "Ellusion no"s initial post, presenting a @ min. decent list, i've decided to give it "my 2cents" as well. Why so? Because this achievement caused me a severe headache! I won't refer intendedly to hints, information, speculation, etc. offered within the variety of comments posted here. Instead i'll make the approach to sum up the requirements in order to unlock this achievement by no doubt. Playing online-coop with a friend, from the start, both of us decided paying attention on this achievement in particular after having finished our 1st playthrough. We used the list above as a checklist doing it from scratch. I can neither confirm nor negate the above list in its present form being adequate or not. In fact, FOR ME, the achievement didn't pop after having ticked off the last weapon from the list. Though we were exact handling our business with care i truely can't tell if we didn't accidently miss something(from the list). Definetly worth mentioning is how i finally unlocked it buying a "Tiefling Bastardsword". Funny about it being having it had previously in my inventory, no doubt! So what i proceeded as follows: loaded up a complete character, worked my way through "Elusion no"s list again by visiting every single merchant in each chapter. In order to be sure as well as able to compare i kept all the weapons i bought. In addition to the weapons listed i bought/picked up a "Warhammer", a "Waraxe" and a "Warstaff"(so in fact a 4th kind of "staffsubtype"). As I said it unlocked by purchasing a weapon i once already had in the inventory - "Tiefling Bastardsword". @ the time this happend the only weapon from the list i didn't have in my present inventory was the "Bastardsword". Having used it an extended amount of time on the 1st playthrough i wasn't caught off guard by this event. Now after analyzing all the data i've gathered around this achievement: there is nothing left but a single detail that possiblely might have gone wrong for me on my 1st attempt. I suspect due 1 or 2 disconnects and deaths(both of us had fallen)linked with the usual resale of the items, not always having manually saved after attaining a required weapon, the game in the end could have missed out on counting few. So my advice in order to successfully unlock this achievement, grown from my own painful experience, would be: pick up/buy all weapons listed above as well as the 1s i mentioned in addition, run a checklist and most importantly manually save your game whenever you've actually made progress towards this achievement.

Thanks for the list. Just want to add that they can be bought as well if you think you are missing a couple and have the gold to spend. If you complete the game you can switch between chapters (make sure you save before doing so in case it doesn't register). Each chapter has at least two or so merchants they seem to randomize each time you switch into them. The more rare and exotic weapons being in the Mouth of the Void chapter.

I have a question, at the time you got this achievement, were you a warrior?

I've came across a lot of weapons as a wizard, beaten the game and reached max level, but hasn't unlocked. I've been asking the same question in the other solution to see as well. But thought It sort of make sense, since it is called "Man at Arms" as the warrior is a male character and usually warriors can use any weapon, but just curious if it is class restricted.

I was a female rogue at the time. If you have the cash, while you're wandering around picking up everything, you can try buying the more exotic weapons, just to make sure. I didn't find my first bastard sword until I was almost 10. I don't remember seeing many bastard swords, heavy picks, and throwing axes. If you see them in the store, try buying one.