WWE 2K17

Select a 1 on 1 match on the main menu. I selected a Tables match, but a Normal match will suffice as well.
Now select two characters and after you pick the 2nd player press Y for Match Options.
Most of the belts are locked. Scroll to one of the available belts. It doesn't matter who it's assigned to. It will still be defended.
Once you win the match and win the belt you will see on the top left side of the screen say "Break" and press the A button to allow you to continue the fight after the match.
Approach your opponent with your newly one title and hit him with it. It may fall out of your hands as soon as you press the A button to continue to fight, but just simply pick it back up with the Left bumper.
Achievement will unlock a couple seconds later.

Select a one-on-one Extreme Rules match (can be any match, but I chose that one). Then select two wrestlers. Hit to go to match options, select title match and then an available title. Hit twice to start the match.

In the top left corner of the screen you'll see hit for a break out. Under that you'll find options for weapons Use the D-Pad to scroll to Championship and hit to break out. Now you can beat down your opponent with the title and get the achievement.