Agatha Christie - The ABC Murders (Xbox One)

Agatha Christie - The ABC Murders (Xbox One)

50 Achievements

1,000

8-10h

PC
Xbox One
Xbox Series
Log in or Register to track Agatha Christie - The ABC Murders (Xbox One) achievements progress.
Large donkey

Large donkey

Have made eight mistakes …

100

2.86%

How to unlock the Large donkey achievement in Agatha Christie - The ABC Murders (Xbox One) - Definitive Guide

There are about 9-10 mistakes you can make in course of the game, which count towards this achievement. I have a confirmed list (thanks to themindisacity of the steamforums for helping) of the mistakes.

These can be done over multiple playthroughs and are saved. The achievement will unlock, when your total of mistakes (each one counts only as one) reaches 8.

Here is the list (there's probably other mistakes, but these ones are confirmed):



According to Stoiss mistakes 6) and 7) count as the same mistake.
28
5

20 Feb 2016 16:26

8 Comments
I think the problem with this achievement is if you deliberately make a mistake, you may not be able to unlock other achievements, forcing a replay. Pretty weird that a detective game rewards you with 200G for being a large donkey.
0
0
By neeker75 on 29 Feb 2016 11:55
Yeah... I thought so as well... In my opinion the developers didn't know the achievment system very well and just randomly put some in there. To deliberately make mistakes really seems tedious.
0
0
By XBU Philippe on 29 Feb 2016 12:06
Great guide! Another mistake may be when Hastings is packing the suitcases before leaving for the second crime scene. Instead of reminding him order is important, I told him it was ok in an emergency.
0
0
By Lord Forbes on 07 Oct 2016 19:49
Mistake 6 and 7 counts as the same mistake in the game, and the suitcase does not count.

I got this on my 3rd try.
0
0
By Stoiss on 19 Dec 2016 04:36
I don't think #2 counts, and I believe telling Thora Grey (when you talk to her in Poirot's apartment near the end of the game) that the Curse of the Dragon is on her is the eighth mistake.
0
0
By Mike Marcelais on 27 Dec 2017 06:03
There are other mistakes that can be made. I made my first one during the reconstruction of the first murder and popped the achievement for making "one" mistake.
0
0
By shadowninja25 on 01 Mar 2018 19:50
Accusing Thora Gray of black magic also counts as a mistake. I was only ever able to make EXACTLY 8 mistakes in the game that counted. These 8 mistakes are outlined in the walkthrough here on TA for the game. I have seen no evidence (while I was playing anyways) that anything except for these mistakes counted for the achievement. I've played 3 times, so I was pretty thorough.

1. Making Mary Cry
2. Saying the murderer is unpredictable
3. Saying the killer is an opportunist and that theft may be motive
4. Asking Thora about her brooch, telling her it scares Lady Clarke and ask her aversion to Franklin
5. Ask Megan not to be in a hurry, agree with Donald that the situation is uncomfortable, ask Megan why Betty didn't say anything.
6. Accusing Thora Grey of black magic.
7. Giving Dudley a heart attack over the phone.
8. Loading the gun with real bullets.

Failing scenarios, making different dialogue choices and not properly packing the suitcase didn't do anything for me. Neither did accusing the fruit seller of being the murderer as stated above. Even royally screwing up your interview with Cust seems to do nothing.
0
0
By UberniXi on 09 Aug 2019 00:41
The game says I have the achievment, but it didn't pop on xbox.
0
0
By Sunny Kloud on 15 Jul 2023 14:26
View all 8 comments Show less comments