As Dusk Falls

Follow my guide above for “once a holt” shortly after you choose to help your family and succeed the qtes you will get another major choice that asks if you would like to surrender, choose surrender to get this achievement.

To earn this achievement you need to surrender to the cops after they find the location of the cabin.

To accomplish this, the cops must know about the cabin. This occurs during the Ash storyline in Chapter 4, when Ash gets saved by Dante you must ensure you reveal the location of the cabin. If in your initial playthrough that was the choice you made, you can load up and start from the "Reunited with Family" section of the story tree in chapter 4. If you hid the location of the cabin in your initial playthrough, then choose to start from the "Hid in Cabin" section of the story tree in chapter 4.

The below guide assumes you have now revealed the cabins location to Dante and you're at the Reunited with Family section.

Not all of these choices are critical, but I'll list all of my choices for the events leading up to the achievement:

"You're okay?"
"I got yours too."
"We stick together!"
"You're right, it doesn't."
QTE fight with Tyler, ensure you win this fight!
Help family.
QTE, make sure you successfully complete this. *Once a Holt will pop here if not previously obtained*
More QTEs, just keep doing them and shooting at the cops.
Surrender.

Jay and Tyler will be arrested, the screen will fade to black, and your achievement will pop.

The approach is to ensure the cops know the cabin location, fight and win against Tyler, choose to help the family, attack the cops until you're overrun, then surrender.

A video of this achievement can be found in the video below, starting at 0:00.

Chapter 4 at the cabin ( Ash tells the truth to Dante in the previous scene ). Help family and surrender to the cops.

For a Full and Fast Achievements Guide check the link below:


Timestamps:

00:00 Intro + Useful Information
02:02 Chapter 1: Story
03:49 Chapter 1: Code Breaker + Smooth Criminal Achievements
05:14 Chapter 1: Message Received + Tables Turned + And So It Begins… Achievements
06:32 Chapter 1: Bungled Achievement
07:16 Chapter 1: Cop Out + Point Blank Achievements
08:18 Chapter 2: What’s Your Emergency? Achievement
09:12 Chapter 2: Story
10:08 Chapter 2: Paging Dr. Walker Achievement
10:57 Chapter 2: Keeping The Faith + Second Chance + Lifesaver Achievements
11:56 Chapter 2: Dodged A Bullet + Caught in a Trap Achievements
12:21 Chapter 2: What’s Done is Done + Unforgiveable Achievements
13:32 Chapter 3: Long Arm of the Law
14:01 Chapter 3: Story
14:24 Chapter 3: Resurrection Achievement
14:48 Chapter 3: Take Me Instead + New Dawn + From Dusk ‘til Dawn Achievements
15:59 Chapter 3: Better the Devil You Know Achievement
16:23 Chapter 3: Buried Alive Achievement
16:44 Chapter 3: She’s Coming with Us Achievement
17:18 Chapter 4: Invincible Achievement
17:49 Chapter 4: Story
18:46 Chapter 4: Cabin? What Cabin? + Brothers in Arms + Into The Woods Achievements
19:46 Chapter 4: Trail of Breadcrumbs + Once a Holt + Hands in the Air + No Going Back Achievement
21:19 Chapter 5: Bullseye Achievement
22:04 Chapter 5: Plead the 5th Achievement
22:28 Chapter 5: Story
22:54 Chapter 5: Jailbird Achievement
23:23 Chapter 5: Heart to Heart + Bonnie and Clyde + Runaways Achievements
24:14 Chapter 5: Cuba Libre Achievement
24:58 Chapter 6: Story (Wait for the Cop)
25:43 Chapter 6: Into the Wild + Breaking Bread + Past, Tense + End of the Road? Achievements
26:56 Chapter 6: Almost Made It + Enough is Enough + Stay of Execution
27:47 Chapter 6: You’re On Your Own (Chapter5) + Free Bird + Most Wanted Achievements