Assassin's Creed Odyssey
93 Achievements
1,850
129-157h
Stink Eye
Recover the Cyclops's eye from a goat on Kephallonia. Details for this achievement will be revealed once unlocked
15
6.01%
How to unlock the Stink Eye achievement in Assassin's Creed Odyssey - Definitive Guide
After doing so, you need to kill goats on the island of Kephallonia and loot their bodies. Near the Coast of Koliadai is a hill where there is a Goat Spawn (See video for Exact Spawn location)
You can always come back to the island at any point if you didn't get this straight after the quest.
**Video Contains Spoilers**
To unlock this achievement you need to recover the Obsidian eye from the goat that you inserted into it during the prologue of the game. Towards the end of the prologue you will eventually confront The Cyclops who has been looking for you and the Obsidian eye you stole from him earlier. When you eventually get the mission to confront The Cyclops, during a cutscene you grab a passing goat and stuff the Obsidian eye up its backside then slap it and it runs off, then you're left to deal with The Cyclops and his men, after which you get your ship and leave the area. However, you can return to Kephallonia when you get free control later on. Once you get free control return to Kephallonia and start your search for the goat. Unfortunately there is no mission nor marker to track it so some luck will be needed.
What I did was to fast travel to the Lightning Zeus statue, then at it's base you will find goats almost permanently respawn around here. Once you're here just start killing goats at random and eventually you will kill the one that has the Obsidian eye. There is no way to tell which goat it is so just keep going and beware of your Eagle also killing goats so that you don't miss any drops from them.
According to the plot, you send the previously stolen eye (prosthetic) of the Cyclops to the Goat and she runs away, after killing the Villain and talking with your new ship captain, go to the hill where the goats will graze, boldly killing each of them and collecting resources should the eye fall out !
I fell from 7-10 goats...
There are about 10-15 goats (goats) walking around there
You kill. I did it with a bow.
Dropped on 11-13
Game v 1.1.4