DARK SOULS: REMASTERED

41 Achievements

1,000

40-50h

Xbox One

Xbox Series

Knight's Honor

Acquire all rare weapons.

2.74%

How to unlock the Knight's Honor achievement in DARK SOULS: REMASTERED - Definitive Guide

vSully

TrueAchievements

26 May 2018 11:26

This achievement hasn't changed from the 360 version of the game even though the original DLC area is included in the remaster. I expected to have to get tail cut weapons and create boss soul weapons from the original game's DLC content, but you don't have to. You just need the original base game's "rare" weapons which I will describe in detail below.

Note that this achievement will require you to play about halfway into the third playthrough as you need three Soul of Sif and access to the Giant Blacksmith in Anor Londo.

Rare weapons fall into a few categories:

Weapons found in static locations

Dragon Crest Shield- found on a corpse near the Undead Dragon in Valley of Drakes
Astora's Straight Sword- found on a corpse near the Undead Dragon in Valley of Drakes
Havel's Greatshield- found in a chest in a room behind an illusory wall in Anor Londo
Dragon Tooth- found in a chest in a room behind an illusory wall in Anor Londo
Dragonslayer Greatbow- found on a corpse in Anor Londo by dropping through a broken glass window in the entrance hall leading to Dragon Slayer Ornstein & Executioner Smough
Black Iron Greatshield- found on a corpse next to the painting in Anor Londo that leads to the Painted World of Ariamis
Velka's Rapier- found on a corpse in Painted World of Ariamis after the Annex Key door
Bloodshield- found on a corpse near the Undead Dragon in Painted World of Ariamis
Effigy Shield- found on a corpse in Tomb of the Giants

Weapons dropped by specific enemies
Some of these weapons are guaranteed drops and some are random drops. You likely will need to farm the appropriate enemies to get all of these weapons.
Increasing your item discovery can help get the weapons to drop more frequently. Consider using the Covetous Gold Serpent ring or the Symbol of Avarice (which do not stack) and having humanity in your counter to increase item discovery.

Black Knight Sword- dropped by sword-wielding Black Knights in Undead Burg, Undead Asylum (second visit), and Kiln of the First Flame (respawning)
Black Knight Greatsword- dropped by greatsword-wielding Black Knights in Undead Parish and Kiln of the First Flame (respawning)
Black Knight Greataxe- dropped by greataxe-wielding Black Knights in The Catacombs and Kiln of the First Flame (respawning)
Black Knight Halberd- dropped by halberd-wielding Black Knights in Darkroot Basin, Tomb of the Giants and Kiln of the First Flame (respawning)
Black Knight Shield- dropped by any Black Knight
Channeler's Trident- dropped by Channelers in the Undead Parish, Depths, and the Duke's Archives (respawning)
Crescent Axe- 100% drop by Patches in The Catacombs, Tomb of the Giants, or Firelink Shrine; sold by Patches upon relocating to Firelink Shrine for 10,000 souls
Crest Shield- 100% drop by Oscar, Knight of Astora in Undead Asylum (return visit).
Demon's Catalyst- 100% drop by Demon Firesage in Demon Ruins
Giant's Halberd- dropped by Sentinels in daylight Anor Londo; sold by Giant Blacksmith for 5,000 souls
Giant's Shield- dropped by Sentinels in daylight Anor Londo; sold by Giant Blacksmith for 10,000 souls (this may not be needed for the achievement)
Izalith Catalyst- 100% drop by Daughter of Chaos in Lost Izalith
Silver Knight Straight Sword- dropped by sword-wielding Silver Knights in Anor Londo
Silver Knight Spear- dropped by spear-wielding Silver Knights in Anor Londo
Silver Knight Shield- dropped by Silver Knights in Anor Londo
Stone Greatsword- dropped by Giant Stone Knights in Darkroot Garden; sold by Shiva of the East for 15,000 souls
Stone Greatshield- dropped by Giant Stone Knights in Darkroot Garden
Grant- 100% drop by Black Phantom Paladin Leeroy in Tomb of the Giants
Sanctus- 100% drop by Black Phantom Paladin Leeroy in Tomb of the Giants

Weapons obtained by joining covenants

Gravelord Sword- join the Gravelord Servant covenant
Dark Hand- join the Darkwraith covenant; also a rare drop by Darkwraiths enemies

Weapons created from boss souls
These weapons can be created by the Giant Blacksmith in Anor Londo and require having the appropriate boss soul and an eligible weapon upgraded to +10

Moonlight Butterfly Horn: requires Soul of the Moonlight Butterfly and any +10 spear or thrusting sword
Crystal Ring Shield: requires Soul of the Moonlight Butterfly and any +10 shield
Quelaag's Furysword: requires Soul of Quelaag and any +10 curved sword
Chaos Blade: requires Soul of Quelaag and any +10 katana
Greatsword of Artorias (Cursed): requires Soul of Sif and any +10 dagger, greatsword, or straight sword other than Broken Straight Sword and Straight Sword Hilt
Greatsword of Artorias: requires Soul of Sif and a +10 Broken Straight Sword or Straight Sword Hilt
Greatshield of Artorias: requires Soul of Sif and any +10 shield
Golem Axe: requires Core of an Iron Golem and any +10 axe
Dragon Bone Fist: requires Core of an Iron Golem and any +10 fist weapon
Lifehunt Scythe: requires Soul of Priscilla and any +10 halberd or whip
Dragonslayer Spear: requires Soul of Ornstein and any +10 spears or thrusting swords
Smough's Hammer: requires Soul of Smough and any +10 hammers or great hammer
Darkmoon Bow: requires Soul of Gwyndolin and any +10 bow
Tin Darkmoon Catalyst: requires Soul of Gwyndolin and any basic catalyst (catalysts don't upgrade)
Great Lord Greatsword: requires Soul of Gwyn, Lord of Cinder and any +10 dagger, greatsword, or straight sword

Weapons that are obtained by cutting specific enemy tails off:

Drake Sword from the Hellkite Dragon in the Undead Berg
Dragon King Greataxe from the Gaping Dragon in the Depths
Priscilla's Dagger from Crossbreed Priscilla in the Painted World of Ariamis
Moonlight Greatsword from Seath the Scaleless in the Crystal Cave
Dragon Greatsword from the Stone Dragon (actually an NPC) in Ash Lake
Gargoyle Tail Axe from the Bell Gargoyles in the Undead Parish or from non-respawing Gargoyles in Anor Londo (note that this is not the weapon they sometimes drop when killed)

As always, refer to http://darksouls.wikidot.com/ for specific information relating to items or locations. This page on the wiki provides full information for all the weapons needed for this achievement.

110

26 May 2018 11:26

43 Comments

Same play through?

By SPΛΙΝΤΞRCΞΛΛ on 05 Jun 2018 21:01

Having trouble getting the trident, any ideas? Been farming in the archives for a while now

By Armyof28388 on 13 Jul 2023 01:35

I have all of the above weapons in my inventory and the achievement has not popped any ideas? The only thing I didn’t do was craft the great lord great sword. I had a buddy do it so I didn’t have to get back to Anor Lado on my third playthrew.

By FireWolf 75 on 06 Jun 2018 14:16

Thats what I mean. Thanks for your answer.

By SPΛΙΝΤΞRCΞΛΛ on 08 Jun 2018 13:17

"These weapons can be created by the Giant Blacksmith in Anor Londo and require ghaving the appropriate boss soul and an eligible weapon upgraded to +10"
I can confirm that ghaving all the boss weapons nets you the achievement.

By JUMS Jumbles on 10 Jun 2018 08:26

If anyone needs some weapons, I have them all and be happy to drop them so you can hold them and get the cheevo. I'm around level 125.

By DevilDwarv on 27 Jun 2018 15:14

I've acquired all of the weapons, minus Priscilla's Dagger (a friend dropped it for me). I've gone through 2 different lists, twice. Not missing any one from either "complete" list. Achievement still hasn't unlocked. Only thing I can think of, is that I have to get Priscilla's Dagger myself...

..::edit::..
Seems like they need to be all in your possession. Read on the Dark Souls Wiki that they need to be in your inventory, not the Bottomless Box. Loaded up the game, started switching weapons from the Box to my inventory. About halfway through, the achievement popped. So that's the only suggestion I can offer for those who have all weapons, but no achievement. Make sure they're not in the bottomless box.

By A ZombieTwinkie on 10 Jul 2018 18:18

I feel like I remembered you only needed to hold a weapon at one point to leave an imprint on your character that you have it. Can anyone confirm that you must have all weapons in your inventory at once to get the achievement, or can you just have had them at one point?

By Shadow XBL on 18 Jul 2018 04:18

On the 360 you just needed to have them at one point. I don't believe it's changed for the remaster.

By Algur on 21 Jul 2018 04:42

Looking to trade for the 8 remaining boss soul weapons I need. Message me if interested.

By Algur on 02 Aug 2018 01:03

messaged you

By Shadow XBL on 02 Aug 2018 06:42

I accidentally sold Havels weapons. Will I find them again in ng plus?

By SPΛΙΝΤΞRCΞΛΛ on 01 Sep 2018 07:13

Yes.

By vSully on 01 Sep 2018 12:05

Hey there! If anyone could just quickly drop the weapons I need I'd appreciate it very much! Its last achievement and I'd like to get it done asap, I also wouldn't mind help anyone with anything else on this game or others we have in common, thanks. :)

By Bigger Plays on 12 Mar 2019 06:25

The Giant's Shield isn't needed for this. Just had the achievement pop and I didn't ever get one.

By Convercide on 02 Jun 2019 12:27

If anyone has an extra soul of Sif that they don't need i will gladly trade for it, SL 132. Beat Sif on my ng+ and not sure what happened to my 2nd one.

By BerserkGrunts on 05 Jun 2019 06:55

if anyone is willing to drop that'd be appreciated.

By Paul Laserbeam on 29 Jun 2019 22:12

Does this require all of the weapons to be on the same character (i.e. do i need to go to NG+2) or can they be aquired over 3 different characters?

By Epic Molby on 07 Nov 2019 19:26

Pretty sure it’s one character.

By vSully on 07 Nov 2019 19:45

do i need the dlc area stuff aswell like cutting kalameets tail?

By WarningCar54796 on 11 Mar 2020 13:51

No. As I said in the first paragraph ;)

By vSully on 11 Mar 2020 13:57

oh sorry forgot to read that part i mainly just skipped to what weapons i needed heh well now i know to read all to next time

By WarningCar54796 on 11 Mar 2020 15:35

I think this achievement for 25G is definitely the achievement needing the most work in history of video games. 3.5 playthroughs of a game.

By CarlosYabrudy on 25 May 2020 05:35

Is there any chance someone could gift me Priscilla's Dagger? Can't ever get the tail cut on that thing and this last time she died without ever reappearing. Would be willing to return the favor as it's the last weapon I need!

By AndrePolarBear on 30 May 2020 16:57

I didn’t got the weapon from the gargoyle tail and I won the achievement. It’s the only weapon that i don’t have, i managed to playthrough and defeat 3 gargoyles and missed the tail. I believe this weapon is NOT needed, but anyway if one wants to get all possible weapons in this game the gargoyle tail axe will be needed.

By GiantBR on 08 Jul 2020 12:55

and even now, the luck was on my side, the trident took me only 10 minutes to get, just like on the 360 version :3

By Damir Malice on 15 Apr 2021 17:15

Not sure if this is helpful to anyone, but I THINK this achievement tracks through multiple save files. I was at the end of my second playthrough and made a mistake with Solaire and couldn't find my way past Gwyn, so I decided to start a new save file. Halfway through my second playthrough I made a number of boss souls, including the 1-2 I hadn't in my first save file, and the achievement popped, with at least 5-6 weapons still on the list for me in this new save file.

All this to say, if you make a mistake like I did, seems possible to start a new save file and focus on the weapons you haven't made yet.

By FalloutImminent on 28 Jan 2022 22:31

ficou me faltando exatamente 3 armas para essa, caso alguém puder me dropar so chamar

By LUCASLUNEEWORD on 11 Mar 2022 02:01

Willing to trade these for DS3 rings.

By Spay001 on 26 May 2022 12:07

i need ((Great Lord Greatsword: Soul of Gwyn, Lord of Cinder)) can anyone help me out plus i need ((Gargoyle Tail Axe))

By mccxm on 25 Jul 2022 02:35

Can anyone help out with the boss souls weapons it'd be much appreciated

By Agrophobic Acky on 02 Aug 2022 19:08

Guide needs to be updated with the “Grant” and “Sanctus” weapons

If you kill Nito before killing Leeroy, he will no longer invade you, so you can’t get the weapons from him, and it will require another play through, you also have to make sure to kill him, and not have him fall off the edge, or you won’t get his weapons as well, and it will require another play through. To get him to spawn you have to place the lordvessel in the altar, but also can’t kill Nito, so it means you CAN NOT just run straight to the tomb of the giants right at the beginning of the game

If anyone can please help me with getting those two weapons so I don’t have to go through everything all over again for a fourth time, just to get those two weapons, it would really help me out

By Psychotic Mr L on 16 Jan 2023 14:17

I found the Greatsword of Artorias and Greatsword of Artorias (Cursed) to be very confusing as there is not difference in the naming of these swords, the only difference is the stats. Just a heads up to anyone also confused by this.

By Kaptain Kaos on 09 Feb 2023 05:27

Can u obtain the achievement if a friend drops all the weapons?

By Manxdovsky on 29 Aug 2023 20:59

I'm not sure what you're asking. If you're asking if all the weapons must be collected within the same playthrough, then the answer is no. You simply must possess all of these weapons and they can (and, unless some are given by a friend, must) be gathered over multiple playthroughs.

By vSully on 05 Jun 2018 21:04

If you're sure that you have all the weapons, then I'm not sure what the problem is. People have been having problems with achievements unlocking, myself included (on my 2nd account). You're the first I've heard with an issue with this achievement, though.

I was able to get some achievements to pop on a second playthrough (progression stuff like Ring the Bell or Reach Anor Londo). Spell collection achievements popped once I acquired an 2nd copy of a spell in NG+. Perhaps getting a 2nd copy of any of the weapons in your next playthrough will fix t for you.

By vSully on 06 Jun 2018 14:45

Anyone will drop some weapons, i need 3 weapons, the greatsword of artorias (normal), the darkmoon bow and the great shield of artorias. SL 143 new londo

By IceFreak95 on 15 Nov 2019 15:19

A massive long shot i know, i was wondering if anybody would be willing to give me either a SIF soul or the cursed greatsword as obviously i made the normal greatsword twice, i REALLY do not want another playthrough!

By WorldOfAtlas on 14 Mar 2020 17:26

Just for clarification, you can upgrade the boss weapons or anything else (crest shield, etc.) and it doesn't affect the achievement. You can use upgraded/changed weapons to ascend to the boss weapons and it doesn't affect the achievement (e.g. I made Ornstein's spear out of an ascended lightning spear). Don't be an IDIOT like me and accidentally ascend the gargoyle tail ax to the Golem Axe via the Iron Golem's boss soul. Luckily it was my third playthrough so I had an extra Iron Golem soul, but such instances don't count, lol. Upgrade all the basic weapons for the boss soul weapons.

By Brennenjamin on 13 Jan 2021 15:16

I have gotten all of the weapons listed and no achievement.. I’ve tried bottomless box, dripping and picking up, and no luck… anyone figure out a way around this?

By rtjr2 on 27 Aug 2023 19:42

If you use the gold (not silver as that boost is for 20% extra souls)serpent ring it will boost item discovery also have some humanity in the corner of the screen, at least 1 will boost discovery by 50, having max of 10 will get to highest chance of items.

By Acurate Bob on 29 Feb 2024 16:05

To anyone who has this achievement, how difficult was it to get the particularly rare drops, specifically the Stone Greatshield (2% drop rate) and, even worse, the Channeler's Trident (1% drop rate). I am aware that the Covetous Gold Serpent Ring and 10 humanity can help boost their likeliness of dropping, but when I was farming Souvenirs of Reprisal for the Darkmoon Covenant, I read that Souvenirs only had a 6% base drop rate. Even with the ring and humanity, it still took quite a while to get enough of them.

How long did it take you to get these two weapons once you started grinding for them? Also, do you have to reverse hollowing in order for the item discovery boost in humanity to take effect?

EDIT: Never mind, I managed to get both weapons fairly easily. Now my latest and possibly final challenge is getting that damn Black Knight Greataxe. Does humanity and the ring effect how often this specific weapon drops?

EDIT: Never mind, I got that, too. Sorry for clogging up the comments section.

By A So So Sniper on 02 Nov 2018 16:53

So I‘m working on the Knight‘s Honor achievement in the Xbox One Version of DSR for a few weeks now and just realized something strange. I‘m currently in NG + and after defeating Sif for the second time I saw that I only have one Soul of Sif in my inventory. At first I thought I might‘ve used it to create a boss weapon already though I was sure I hadn’t, so I checked like 10 times (also inside the bottomless box) and there‘s nothing there. I‘m also 100% sure I haven‘t used it to gain souls (at least definitely not on purpose). So if anyone could help me out and drop a Soul of Sif for me it would be grately appreciated! (Xbox One, level 96. It‘s especially frustrating because I have done every requirement for the achievement up to this point and I‘d rather not start NG+4 (cause you need at least 3 of his souls) If you‘d like I‘d drop anything you want in return except for the items required for this achievement. Thanks!

TL;DR:
I‘m asking for help to get a Soul of Sif in NG + of DSR on Xbox One since I apparently have just one Soul of Sif after defeating him twice.

By JanGLL on 19 Jun 2018 21:12

View all 43 comments Show less comments

Oreos Are Legit

TrueAchievements

27 May 2018 09:09

I've made a google sheet checklist for Knight's Honor, Wisdom of a Sage, Bond of a Pyromancer and Prayer of a Maiden. Slight Spoilers included in the document. It comes with every item needed to get these achievements in a list along with a brief description on how to acquire the item and a link to the items wiki page on Fextralife. You'll need to save the document to your own drive before it'll allow you to start checking things off. You can find the link to it here: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1IBAR9dAKxKPzW5UA31Mo...

27 May 2018 09:09

3 Comments

Very nice! Love the links to a wiki for more info.

By crunchb3rry on 03 Jul 2018 04:48

Anyone who makes a checklist for things like this is my new BFF.

By AllChristophe on 29 Jul 2019 14:05

Great checklist, thank you. But it's missing the Gargoyle Tail Axe.

By Mittensne on 03 Jan 2020 19:33

View all 3 comments Show less comments

v_Sully

TrueTrophies

09 Aug 2018 21:09

This trophy hasn't changed from the PS3 version of the game even though the original DLC area is included in the remaster. I expected to have to get tail cut weapons and create boss soul weapons from the original game's DLC content, but you don't have to. You just need the original base game's "rare" weapons which I will describe in detail below.

Note that this trophy will require you to play about halfway into the third playthrough as you need three Soul of Sif and access to the Giant Blacksmith in Anor Londo.

Rare weapons fall into a few categories:

Weapons found in static locations

Dragon Crest Shield- found on a corpse near the Undead Dragon in Valley of Drakes
Astora's Straight Sword- found on a corpse near the Undead Dragon in Valley of Drakes
Havel's Greatshield- found in a chest in a room behind an illusory wall in Anor Londo
Dragon Tooth- found in a chest in a room behind an illusory wall in Anor Londo
Dragonslayer Greatbow- found on a corpse in Anor Londo by dropping through a broken glass window in the entrance hall leading to Dragon Slayer Ornstein & Executioner Smough
Black Iron Greatshield- found on a corpse next to the painting in Anor Londo that leads to the Painted World of Ariamis
Velka's Rapier- found on a corpse in Painted World of Ariamis after the Annex Key door
Bloodshield- found on a corpse near the Undead Dragon in Painted World of Ariamis
Effigy Shield- found on a corpse in Tomb of the Giants

Weapons dropped by specific enemies
Some of these weapons are guaranteed drops and some are random drops. You likely will need to farm the appropriate enemies to get all of these weapons.
Increasing your item discovery can help get the weapons to drop more frequently. Consider using the Covetous Gold Serpent ring or the Symbol of Avarice (which do not stack) and having humanity in your counter to increase item discovery.

Black Knight Sword- dropped by sword-wielding Black Knights in Undead Burg, Undead Asylum (second visit), and Kiln of the First Flame (respawning)
Black Knight Greatsword- dropped by greatsword-wielding Black Knights in Undead Parish and Kiln of the First Flame (respawning)
Black Knight Greataxe- dropped by greataxe-wielding Black Knights in The Catacombs and Kiln of the First Flame (respawning)
Black Knight Halberd- dropped by halberd-wielding Black Knights in Darkroot Basin, Tomb of the Giants and Kiln of the First Flame (respawning)
Black Knight Shield- dropped by any Black Knight
Channeler's Trident- dropped by Channelers in the Undead Parish, Depths, and the Duke's Archives (respawning)
Crescent Axe- 100% drop by Patches in The Catacombs, Tomb of the Giants, or Firelink Shrine; sold by Patches upon relocating to Firelink Shrine for 10,000 souls
Crest Shield- 100% drop by Oscar, Knight of Astora in Undead Asylum (return visit).
Demon's Catalyst- 100% drop by Demon Firesage in Demon Ruins
Giant's Halberd- dropped by Sentinels in daylight Anor Londo; sold by Giant Blacksmith for 5,000 souls
Giant's Shield- dropped by Sentinels in daylight Anor Londo; sold by Giant Blacksmith for 10,000 souls (this may not be needed for the achievement)
Izalith Catalyst- 100% drop by Daughter of Chaos in Lost Izalith
Silver Knight Straight Sword- dropped by sword-wielding Silver Knights in Anor Londo
Silver Knight Spear- dropped by spear-wielding Silver Knights in Anor Londo
Silver Knight Shield- dropped by Silver Knights in Anor Londo
Stone Greatsword- dropped by Giant Stone Knights in Darkroot Garden; sold by Shiva of the East for 15,000 souls
Stone Greatshield- dropped by Giant Stone Knights in Darkroot Garden
Grant- 100% drop by Black Phantom Paladin Leeroy in Tomb of the Giants
Sanctus- 100% drop by Black Phantom Paladin Leeroy in Tomb of the Giants

Weapons obtained by joining covenants

Gravelord Sword- join the Gravelord Servant covenant
Dark Hand- join the Darkwraith covenant; also a rare drop by Darkwraiths enemies

Weapons created from boss souls
These weapons can be created by the Giant Blacksmith in Anor Londo and require having the appropriate boss soul and an eligible weapon upgraded to +10

Moonlight Butterfly Horn: requires Soul of the Moonlight Butterfly and any +10 spear or thrusting sword
Crystal Ring Shield: requires Soul of the Moonlight Butterfly and any +10 shield
Quelaag's Furysword: requires Soul of Quelaag and any +10 curved sword
Chaos Blade: requires Soul of Quelaag and any +10 katana
Greatsword of Artorias (Cursed): requires Soul of Sif and any +10 dagger, greatsword, or straight sword other than Broken Straight Sword and Straight Sword Hilt
Greatsword of Artorias: requires Soul of Sif and a +10 Broken Straight Sword or Straight Sword Hilt
Greatshield of Artorias: requires Soul of Sif and any +10 shield
Golem Axe: requires Core of an Iron Golem and any +10 axe
Dragon Bone Fist: requires Core of an Iron Golem and any +10 fist weapon
Lifehunt Scythe: requires Soul of Priscilla and any +10 halberd or whip
Dragonslayer Spear: requires Soul of Ornstein and any +10 spears or thrusting swords
Smough's Hammer: requires Soul of Smough and any +10 hammers or great hammer
Darkmoon Bow: requires Soul of Gwyndolin and any +10 bow
Tin Darkmoon Catalyst: requires Soul of Gwyndolin and any basic catalyst (catalysts don't upgrade)
Great Lord Greatsword: requires Soul of Gwyn, Lord of Cinder and any +10 dagger, greatsword, or straight sword

Weapons that are obtained by cutting specific enemy tails off:

Drake Sword from the Hellkite Dragon in the Undead Berg
Dragon King Greataxe from the Gaping Dragon in the Depths
Priscilla's Dagger from Crossbreed Priscilla in the Painted World of Ariamis
Moonlight Greatsword from Seath the Scaleless in the Crystal Cave
Dragon Greatsword from the Stone Dragon (actually an NPC) in Ash Lake
Gargoyle Tail Axe from the Bell Gargoyles in the Undead Parish or from non-respawing Gargoyles in Anor Londo (note that this is not the weapon they sometimes drop when killed)

As always, refer to http://darksouls.wikidot.com/ for specific information relating to items or locations. This page on the wiki provides full information for all the weapons needed for this achievement.

09 Aug 2018 21:09

2 Comments

You can actually be summoned by someone and have them drop all the needed weapons and the trophy will pop. It is quite cheap but I'm surprised it actually works so if you have a really generous friend (or someone who can save scum their account by using a USB or the PS+ cloud) you can use this to shortcut getting this trophy. Sadly this doesn't work for the spells needed for the other collectible trophies.

By RealBlazeStorm on 03 May 2021 06:26

I've had a hard time summoning friends to help with this trophy. Everything was set, bosses still alive, summon range, soap stone etc. Nothing worked out. So I ended up farming this myself.

+1 for the guide here regardless.

By PLATINBLAZE on 19 Mar 2022 16:01

Archer Spense

TrueAchievements

03 Oct 2019 08:35

The one weapon for this achievement I had trouble getting was for cutting off Priscilla's tail.

As far as I know, Priscilla turns invisible as soon as the fight starts and does not reappear unless you hit her @3 times very quickly. She's fragile, and her health bar also disappears, so its very easy to kill her before you can get her to reappear.

If you happen to be like me and can't cut Priscilla's tail off in one hit like videos show, here's what to do:

have pyromancy flame equipped
have fire storm, fire tempest, or chaos storm attuned and cast it when she goes invisible
it should reveal her

once you can see her again, its easy to strafe around and cut her tail off.

you WILL kill her if you try to cut it off while she's invisible. Don't even try.

03 Oct 2019 08:35

1 Comment

Option two, without using pyromancy would be to use a very weak weapon in your 2nd weapon slot to hit at her when she's in stealth. This will allow you to break her out of stealth without doing much damage to her. Switch back to your main weapon when she's visible and attack the tail. If it looks like you're going to kill her too soon, you can always homeward bone out to try again.

By FruitofPassion on 02 Jun 2020 18:18

Dropeti

PlaystationTrophies

To unlock this trophy you are required to hold, at the same time, all of the considered 'rare' weapons of the game. This includes all the weapons forged with bosses souls, all of the weapons acquired by cutting the tail of specific bosses and other ones. Shields included in these also count for the trophy. Note that not all weapons that use Twinkling Titanites to upgrade are required for the trophy.

This is the trophy that will require you to play the game at least two full times and a half, solely because one of the bosses soul (Great Grey Wolf Sif's) is required to forge three different weapons.

You can achieve this trophy by getting all weapons through multiple characters' games.
For the Knights Honor trophy, it says you can get the weapons on any amount of characters. I got every weapon amongst my 4 characters and it didn't unlock, so I went and researched about it and it seems to be a glitch. You're supposed to get all weapons on a single character to get the trophy, but sometimes it will glitch and allow you to get them amongst any characters. Thanks [PS3T]kira!

Below is a list of everything required for this trophy along with the information on how to obtain it. Big thanks to Blood_Runs_Cold for compiling most of the information in here!

If you want, you can use the printable checklist from HERE made by Birr1978 to help you keep track of what you have.

--Weapons & Shields Dropped by Enemies, Looted or Acquired by Joining Covenants

Astoria's Straight Sword:
Valley of Drakes. In front of the poison-spilling Zombie Dragon.

Black Knight Greataxe:
Dropped by Greataxe-Wielding Black Knights. You can find unlimited Black Knights right before the final boss fog door to farm it if you need.

Black knight Greatsword:
Random drop from any Greatsword-Wielding Black Knights in the game. You can find unlimited Black Knights right before the final boss fog door to farm it if you need.

Black Knight Halberd:
Dropped by Spear-Wielding Black Knights. You can find unlimited Black Knights right before the final boss fog door to farm it if you need.

Black Knight Shield:
Dropped by any Black Knights in the game. You can find unlimited Black Knights right before the final boss fog door to farm it if you need.

Black Knight Sword:
Random drop from any Sword Wielding Black Knight in the game. You can find unlimited Black Knights right before the final boss fog door to farm it if you need.

Blood Shield:
Painted World of Ariamis. On the bridge after the Dagon Zombie Fight.

Channeler's Trident:
Dropped from the Mage enemies. In the Duke's Archives they are respawnable.

Crest Shield:
Undead Asylum (Revisited). Kill the soldier who gave you the flask the first time you were here.

Crescent Axe:
Dropped from Patches in the Tomb of the Giants, or bought from Patches in Firelink Shrine.

Dark Hand:
Joining gift for Darkwraith Covenant.

Dragon Crest Shield:
Valley of Drakes. In front of the poison-spilling Zombie Dragon.

Dragon Tooth:
Anor Londo. Same room as Havel's Greatshield. From the third bonfire (the one inside the building) go through one of the doors and down the stairs to find two chests guarded by two Knights.

Dragonslayer Greatbow:
Anor Londo. In the main building where there are two staircases on each side you can find a cracked window on the top floor. Go through it and carefully roll to the enclosed area down below with the corpse and the loot.

Effigy Shield:
Tomb of Giants. After the first bonfire of the area but before the first fog door, turn to your left and go down the hole. The shield is in a tunnel in that area.

Giant's Halberd:
Bought for 5000 souls at Giant Blacksmith, or dropped from the giant knights in the same area.

Grant:
Tomb of Giants. Dropped by NPC invader "Divine Knight Leeroy". He will invade you in the way to the boss fight if you are in Human form.

Gravelord Sword:
Reward for joining the Gravelord Servant covenant.

Havel's Greatshield:
Anor Londo. Same room as the Dragon Tooth. From the third bonfire (the one inside the building) go through one of the doors and down the stairs to find two chests guarded by two Knights.

Sanctus:
Tomb of Giants. Dropped by NPC invader "Divine Knight Leeroy". He will invade you in the way to the boss fight if you are in Human form.

Silver Knight Shield:
Anor Londo. Dropped by any Silver Knight type.

Silver Knight Spear:
Anor Londo. Dropped by any Spear-wielding Silver Knight.

Silver Knight Straight Sword:
Anor Londo. Dropped by any Sword-wielding Silver Knight.

Stone Greatshield:
Darkroot Garden. Both the shield and the sword are dropped by any Stone Knight laying around before the Moonilight Butterfly boss.

Stone Greatsword:
Darkroot Garden. Both the shield and the sword are dropped by any Stone Knight laying around before the Moonilight Butterfly boss. Alternatively, you can buy it from the merchant Shiva of the East in Blightown for 15,000 souls if you are part of the Forest Hunter covenant.

Velka's Rapier:
Painted World of Ariamis. Found in a corpse inside the Annex area, behind a breakable door.

--Weapons & Shields Forged With Bosses' Souls--

Bosses Souls required:
1x Soul of Ornstein (Acquired by killing Smough first in the Boss battle)
1x Soul of Smough (Acquired by killing Ornstein first in the Boss battle)
1x Soul of Priscilla
2x Soul of Gwyn, Lord of Cinder (One of them being for a miracle)
2x Soul of Moonlight Butterfly
2x Soul of Quelaag
2x Soul of Iron Golem
2x Soul of Gwindolyn
3x Soul of Great Gray Wolf Sif

Dragonslayer Spear:
Ascend any +10 rapier type weapon or spear and the soul of Ornstein, one of the bosses of Anor Londo for this weapon.

--Compatible Weapons--
Mail Breaker
Estoc
Rapier
Ricard's Rapier
Spear
Winged Spear
Partizan
Pike

Smough's Hammer:
Must ascend a +10 club/mace and the soul of Smough, one of the bosses of Anor Londo to get this weapon.

--Compatible Weapons--
Club
Mace
Morning Star
Warpick
Pickaxe
Reinforced Club
Greatclub
Demon's Great Hammer
Large Club

Lifehunt Scythe:
Ascend any +10 Halberd/scythe and the soul of Priscilla, the Half Breed to get this weapon.

--Compatible Weapons--
Halberd
Luceme
Scythe
Gargoyle's Halberd
Great Scythe
Whip
Notched Whip

Great Lord Greatsword:
You must ascend a +10 weapon and the soul of Gwyn, The Lord of Cinder.

--Compatible Weapons--
Dagger
Parrying Dagger
Bandit's Knife
Demon Great Machete
Greatsword
Zweihander
Flamberge
Man-Serpent Greatsword
Claymore
Bastardsword
Darksword
Barbed Straightsword
Sunlight Straightsword
Baldre Sidesword
Broadsword
Longsword
Shortsword

Moonlight Butterfly Horn:
Ascend any +10 Spear or rapier and the soul of the Moonlight Butterfly for this weapon.

--Compatible Weapons--
Mail Breaker
Estoc
Rapier
Ricard's Rapier
Spear
Winged Spear
Pike

Crystal Ring Shield:
Ascend a +10 shield/buckler and the soul of The Moonlight Butterfly to get this shield.

--Compatible Shields--
Plank Shield
Small Leather Shield
Leather Shield
Target Shield
Buckler
Cracked Round Shield
Red And White Round Shield
Warrior's Round Shield
Heater Shield
Knight Shield
Tower Kite Shield
Grass Crest Shield
Hollow Soldier Shield
Balder Shield
Iron Round Shield
Spider Shield
Spiked Shield
pierce Shield
Sunlight Shield
Cadeceus Kite Shield
Gargoyle's Shield
Double Headed Eagle Shield
Wooden Shield
Large Leather Shield
Eagle Shield
Tower Shield
Giant Shield
Bonewheel Shield
Effigy Shield
Sanctus/Bloodshield
Black Iron Greatshield

Quelaag's Furysword:
You must ascend a +10 weapon using the soul of Quelaag, the boss to ring the second bell. A good weapon to use would be a Scimtar purchased pretty cheap from the Undead merchant in Undead Burg.

--Compatible Weapons--
Painting Guardian Sword
Murakumo
Server
Shotel
Scimitar
Falchion

Chaos Blade:
You must ascend a +10 weapon and the soul of Quelaag. A good choice is the Iaito found in Blighttown.

--Compatible Weapons--
Washing Pole
Iaito
Uchigatana

Golem Axe:
Make a +10 axe and use the core of the Iron Golem to ascen this weapon.

--Compatible Weapons--
Handaxe
Demon's Greataxe
Greataxe
Gargoyle Tailaxe
Butcher Knife
battleaxe

Dragonbone Fist:
Ascend any +10 Cestus or claw and the core of the Iron Golem fot this weapon.

--Compatible Weapons--
Cestus
Claw

Tin Darkmoon Catylist:
Ascend any catylist and the soul of Gwyndolin, The Darkmoon God to get this weapon.

--Compatible Weapons--
Oolicile Ivory Catylist
Logan's Catylist
Tin Banishment Catylist
Sorcerer's Catylist
Beatrice's Catylist

Darkmoon Bow:
Ascend any +10 Bow and the soul of Gwyndolin to get this weapon.

--Compatible Weapons--
Short Bow
Composite Bow
Long Bow
Dark Bow of Pharis

Greatshield of Artorias:
You must ascend pretty much any +10 shield/buckler and the soul of Sif, The Great Grey Wolf to aquire this shield.

Greatsword of Artorias:
You must Ascend a +10 straight sword with the soul of Sif, The Great Gray Wolf.
Despite the name being the same, this version of the Greatsword of Artorias does NOT do magic damage, while the other one does. On the other hand this version is capable of damaging ghosts.

--Compatible Weapons--
Dagger
Parrying Dagger
Bandit's Knife
Greatsword
Zweihander
Flamberge
Man-Serpent Greatsword
Claymore
Darksword
Sunlight Straightsword
Balder Sidesword
Broadsword
Longsword
Shortsword

Greatsword of Artorias:
You must ascend a +10 Broken sword dropped by the sword weilding zombies of Undead Burg/Parish and the soul of Sif, The Great Gray Wolf.
Despite the name being the same, this version of the Greatsword of Artorias DOES magic damage, while the other one doesn't.

--Compatible Weapons--
Broken Straight Sword
Straight Sword Hilt

MutesVPN

TrueAchievements

06 Sep 2023 00:15

I have not finished the remastered version yet, but I did 100% the original 360 release of this game.

From what I have seen, it is the exact same process as the original Xbox 360 release. You do not need the DLC weapons for this, just the bas game weapons.

There are plenty of lists and guides for this achievement, however I did not see any mention this.

If you have a friend who already has this achievement, or has a few weapons you do not have, as long as they are within a certain level range within yours (I believe it's within 10-20 levels between each other. Basically as long as you can join their game) they can drop the missing weapons and you should get the achievement. My friend dropped me a few weapons from his playthrough I some how missed and it still counted fo rmy achievement .

The Channeler's Trident took me literally 15 hours to farm because the drop rate is so low, so if you can, I would find someone online who has it to drop it for you.

06 Sep 2023 00:15

Mihawk

stratege.ru

28 May 2018 21:59

This guide was translated automatically.

Boss Soul Weapons

Moon Butterfly Horn
Shield with crystal ring
Quileg's Furious Sword
Blade of Chaos
Cursed Sword of Artorias
Heavenly Sword of Artorias
Greatshield of Artorias
Golem Ax
Dragon bone fist
Scythe of life taking
Dragonslayer Spear
Smough's Hammer
Dark Moon Bow
Darkmoon Iron Staff
Great Sword of the Great Overlord

Weapons from the tails

Dragon Sword
Greataxe of the Dragon King
Priscilla's Dagger
Great Moon Sword
Great Dragon Sword
Tail-axe

Covenant weapons

Grave Lord's Sword
Dark Hand (can also be dropped from Dark Spirit)

Weapons from enemies

Shield with emblem
Stone greatsword
Stone large shield
Silver straight sword
Spear of the Silver Knight
Shield of the Silver Knight
Black Knight Sword
Great Sword of the Black Knight
Greataxe of the Black Knight
Halberd of the Black Knight
Shield of the Black Knight
Spiritual Trident
Semicircular ax
Giant Halberd
Ricardian rapier
Staff of Izalith
Demon Staff

Weapons from dark phantoms

Grant
Sanctus

Weapons from chests and corpses

Shield with dragon emblem
Astor Straight Sword
Great Shield of Havel
Dragon Tooth
Dragonslayer's Longbow
Welky's Rapier
Bloody Shield
Carved shield
Black shield

28 May 2018 21:59

9 Comments

when you make the celestial and cursed sword of Artorias, keep in mind that they will be listed as “great sword of Artorias” in the giant blacksmith’s crafting menu with all the necessary materials (that is, for the celestial one, I upgraded the hilt of a straight sword + 10 + soul of Sif , and for the damned I upgraded a snake great sword + 10 + soul of Sif)

By PsVano87 on 17 Aug 2018 06:43

I will add that in order not to waste time on the third playthrough, upgrade the necessary weapons to +10 for weapons from the souls of Sif and Gwyn before the end of the second playthrough. On the third, all that remains is to kill Sif and run to the blacksmith with whom you can simply exchange souls..

By Zombie on 20 Aug 2018 10:14

I would like to add that you don’t make my mistakes if you want to assemble all the equipment yourself. There are two weapons from the souls of Smough and Ornstein (Smough's Hammer and Dragonslayer's Spear). These are two bosses that you fight at the same time. So, the soul falls only from the one who was killed last. And usually they kill Ornstein first, since it’s much easier, and in the end we don’t get his soul. Be careful.

By crazy_creatiff on 09 Oct 2019 15:23

We encountered the following problem: if a weapon is sharpened, then the other player does not see it + the difference in levels should not be more or less than 10% of the summoner’s level.

By GiMMer on 02 Sep 2020 18:30

an already made sword can be safely used again. For example, at ng+3, to forge a sword from Gwyn’s soul, I needed any straight sword at +10, but it wasn’t in my inventory, I successfully converted Artorias’s sword into a regular straight sword +10.
So, the game already counts weapons once made not by the fact of their existence, but by the fact of their creation.

By dietoday on 04 May 2024 23:58

Paladin Leroy only appears if you are in human form. If it doesn’t appear, at the exit from the Crypt of Giants to the boss Nito (where there was a yellow barrier before receiving the great bowl), make an exit - off. network mode (or on), restart again and change back. We go towards Nito and Leroy will appear.

By TermaZ on 10 Mar 2024 10:29

Received Knight's Honor (and platinum) without the Half-Circular Axe.

By Ac1dgreen on 25 May 2019 12:08

I don't know about "without a semi-circular axe", I only had it with him. So the last action before platinum for me is killing Patchwork) But this is in boxing, if anything

By Antoine_soverie on 15 Jan 2020 20:26

I encountered the following problem - it is impossible to collect Grant and Sanctus, due to a known bug -

By Prohodimets on 08 Feb 2021 07:45

View all 9 comments Show less comments

RLAquatIX

stratege.ru

25 May 2018 12:25

This guide was translated automatically.

Please note that collecting all rare weapons is counted on one character, i.e. weapons must be collected in the inventory of one character and only then will the achievement be counted. The same applies to other similar collection achievements: "
Wisdom of a Sage, Bond of a Pyromancer, Prayer of a Maiden, Prayer of a Maiden

25 May 2018 12:25