Gears of War 4

Gears of War 4

164 Achievements

4,000

458-620h

PC
Xbox One
Xbox Series
Log in or Register to track Gears of War 4 achievements progress.
Judge, Jury and Executioner

Judge, Jury and Executioner

You've slayed up in style by performing every unique execution. Inspired by Blowfish666.

50

0.24%

How to unlock the Judge, Jury and Executioner achievement in Gears of War 4 - Definitive Guide

Note: Several people have reported the the Dropshot execution is not registering at the moment. Right now, there doesn't seem to be a solution to this problem. Could be a server side issue or, knowing how TC operate, they've broken something in this recent update.

Note Update: A couple players experiencing the Dropshot issue have managed to get it to register after hard resetting their console and trying again.

----------------------------------------------------

So, this achievement pays tribute to one from Gears 3. The objective is the same, perform one of every execution. That's all the basic weapons, power weapons, bag and tag with a grenade and a drag-over-cover knife execution. For all of the executions, you will need to down the opponent and then hold cn_Y on their body.

Additionally, the achievement can be done in private play with a second controller). Connect a second controller to your console and press the menu button. Sign in a guest or a second profile. When you go into private play, you'll be COG and your second controller will be swarm.

From the main menu, select Versus and then Private Play. Select Team Deathmatch. If you press the menu button, you'll be able to tweak match settings as well as what weapons spawn on the map. This is useful if you can't remember which weapons are on which map.

This achievement is also trackable so turn on your achievement tracker to see if the execution registers.

If you're also unsure of which weapons you've done an execution with go into your War Journal and check your weapons. War Journal > Press cn_LT > Scroll with your right thumb stick. Your stats should show how many executions you've done for most of the weapons.

Weapons:
- Lancer
- Hammerburst
- Gnasher
- Enforcer
- Markza
- Torque Bow
- Boltok
- Dropshot
- Boomshot
- Retro Lancer
- Embar
- Overkill
- Longshot

Power Weapons:
- Buzzkill
- Mulcher
- Tri Shot
- Salvo

On top of this, you'll need to perform:
- Bag and Tag: Pick up grenades, down and enemy, press cn_X on their body and then press cn_up on the d-pad
- Knife Execution: Place your second controller behind cover, go on the opposite side of him against the cover, push cn_LSu on your left thumb stick and then press cn_X to drag him over. Press cn_Y to knife execute him

I was stuck at 89% until a friend pointed out that these two needed to be performed again in order for them to register.

Unsure of this one but ... down an opponent, select your snub pistol and then press cn_Y to execute him. You'll perform a beat down. Again, unsure if this one counts so could someone confirm please? Thanks.

That everything I can think of. If you have any suggestions on how to improve the solution or any more information to add, please comment below. If you leave a negative vote, please state why. Thanks.

--------------------------

Edit 1: This achievement is retrospective meaning you will already have progress towards it prior to this update (Thanks Yurgi Windu)

Edit 2: another knife execution to do would be to vault over cover and kick your opponent then hit cn_Y to execute (Thanks The SCHWARTZ 00)

Edit 3: Drag-over-cover knife execution and bag and tag executions have been confirmed to NOT be retroactive Thanks to CodeMonkeyGuy and Anthony2690

Edit 4: The neck snap execution also counts for this achievement. Thanks to T Dawg182 and shelbygt5252. I believe it's retroactive as I didn't need to do it for my achievement.

Edit 5: The Snub Beat down execution also seems to be retroactive. Thanks to iguanadude626.

Edit 6: Fed kaffe has made a tracker that's shows exact progress to the achievement https://xbltracker.com/
163
5

08 Nov 2018 23:13

41 Comments
You can turn off bots in the setting when you press the menu button. Then, you'll be one-on-one with the second controller and can just run across the map.
0
0
By darkavenger786 on 08 Nov 2018 23:36
Oh yeah I get that what I mean is you will need to turn bots ON to do the grenade one only. smile
0
0
By FiveWizz on 08 Nov 2018 23:39
O, no. I did it without bots and it registered
0
0
By darkavenger786 on 08 Nov 2018 23:44
Oh nice one fair enough. I had to get bots on for that but it worked perfectly anyway so no qualms.

Upvote from me this is exactly what I needed to know. Cheers.
0
0
By FiveWizz on 08 Nov 2018 23:47
You're welcome smile
0
0
By darkavenger786 on 08 Nov 2018 23:50
Should note this is retrospective. I had 63% completion as soon as I updated.
0
0
By Yurgi Windu on 09 Nov 2018 01:19
If anyone is missing one, try doing the knife kill where you kick an opponent in the back and slit his throat from behind. He has to be facing away from you and aiming at something else close to cover. I did this in a private match and the achievement popped.
0
0
By The SCHWARTZ 00 on 09 Nov 2018 01:20
Yeah I think the knife kill might not be retroactive, or some form thereof. I just did Deadly Resourceful, and I noticed afterward that I had progress on this achievement. Only thing I did in terms of executions leading up to the Swarmak was knife kills... one was a drag-over-cover, and one was a kick.
0
0
By CodeMonkeysGuy on 09 Nov 2018 01:56
Thank you :)

Turns out knife kill and bag and tag are not retroactive.

Was at 89% and was certain if already done everything.
0
0
By anthony2690 on 09 Nov 2018 02:06
Meatshield necksnap also counts. It was the one I needed that popped the achievement. Maybe that one was not retroactive, I was pretty sure I had done those before, but I was stuck at 94% before it popped when I did this one.
0
0
By T Dawg182 on 09 Nov 2018 02:33
I can confirm that meatshield necksnap counts, was at 94% and popped after I read your comment
0
0
By shelbygt5252 on 09 Nov 2018 02:46
Same as Shelby, was stuck at 94%, then I snapped the neck of the meatshield and it popped.
0
0
By DrSchlepenstein on 09 Nov 2018 03:23
the snub beatdown is retroactive I think. coz Im pretty sure I did a few when i was super active in gears 4. lol
mine didnt % increase even when I did for latest achivement last kill with snub execution.
0
0
By iguanadude626 on 09 Nov 2018 04:15
Thank you all for the various comments and input. It's is greatly appreciated. Credit has been given where credit is due smile
0
0
By darkavenger786 on 09 Nov 2018 07:42
Dropshot won't count an execution for me in the war journal, pretty cool...
0
0
By on 09 Nov 2018 10:14
I'm having the same problem as Westworld, stuck on 94% and the Dropshot just won't register.
0
0
By Monomythic on 09 Nov 2018 13:20
The neck snap is not retroactive as I unlocked the achievement by doing it. I'm pretty sure I had already done it before.

You may add:

Neck Snap
Swarm beatdown
COG beatdown
Curb Stomp
0
0
By rafa1000house on 09 Nov 2018 14:14
Thanks Fed. Added to the solution
0
0
By darkavenger786 on 09 Nov 2018 16:23
Unsure what to do about the dropshot. Have you tried hard resetting your console?
0
0
By darkavenger786 on 09 Nov 2018 20:15
Dropshot wasn’t working for me, hard reset my console and worked on the 2nd try
0
0
By Swyer87 on 09 Nov 2018 20:49
Excellent. I'll add it now smile
0
0
By darkavenger786 on 09 Nov 2018 21:11
My last one was bag’n TAG with a shock grenade.
So u need all the different grenades for this one. Not just any type!
0
0
By Charlie Lima on 10 Nov 2018 14:27
You need to hold Y to execute, not press Y.
0
0
By HolyHalfDead on 11 Nov 2018 09:11
Edited. Thanks
0
0
By darkavenger786 on 11 Nov 2018 10:05
Boltok is not required, please remove it from your list.
0
0
By Darth Hawk CZ on 11 Nov 2018 15:45
A hard job, fortunately this achievement is retroactive. When I started the game after the update I already was with 49% of progress. Unfortunately I did not know which executions I already had. I started from zero. Really some executions aren't retroactive.
0
0
By netstryker on 13 Nov 2018 23:48
The tracker that Fed provided should help you figure out which ones you're missing. Good luck.
0
0
By darkavenger786 on 13 Nov 2018 23:49
I was stuck at 89%, both longshot and overkill did not register, had to hard reset twice. Thanks for the tracker Fed, well done!
0
0
By Onik PL on 12 Mar 2019 16:34
I was stuck on 94% and noticed the weapon RL-4 SALVO doesn't say how many executions u have unlike all other weapons, So try the SALVO mine popped after 2 executions. 👍
0
0
By on 16 Apr 2019 11:44
Thanks so much for the website! @Fed kaffe!!
0
0
By Viva Vizionz on 16 Jun 2019 15:00
Just did this on Win 10 today. Dropshot execution count on War Jorurnal is still 0 despite doing it a few times.
However did bag and tag with a frag grenade to get to 100%
Also dont forget to go into cover, jump and grab them and press Y to slash thier throat - i think that counted as one of mine despite having done that years ago, it must have reset to 0 once these cheevos came out. Good luck
0
0
By BROADBANNED on 13 Jul 2019 13:55
Any suggestions for getting the Trishot Execution in campaign?
0
0
By Robster80 on 03 Sep 2019 12:11
+1 for if you're stuck at 94% and have all the weapons, do the yank n shank.

For heavy weapons such as the Trishot or Mulcher, I played vs casual bots. Grab the weapon, try to find an isolated enemy. Swap to lancer and down him then pick your heavy back up and finish 'em.
0
0
By Chucklestyle on 14 Mar 2020 20:56
Dropshot wasnt working for me. Ended up hard resetting and got it done in a private warzone match on the second execution
0
0
By ryancot96 on 07 Mar 2021 01:09
Play easy difficulty horde (still has some people now), you may complete most except those weapons enemies don’t have (for example longshot and markza need buy or be a sniper)
0
0
By Pure as Null on 25 Aug 2022 14:17
Anyone have the Boltok not registering? As per the xbltracker I still need the Boltok, but have done well over a dozen of em.

**Edit - I discovered that the xbltracker doesn’t show the knife execution and that was the one that popped it, and removed the Boltok execution listed. Thank gawd, I thought it was glitched.
0
0
By Leigrez on 27 Mar 2023 04:44
FYI I had to do a snub execution on the COG team for it to count.
0
0
By Ub3 xTr1PpiNx on 06 Jun 2023 22:59
Only comment so far is if you want to play private only against one person you'll need to fill with bots actually for the grenade one otherwise they die before u get to do it.

But can confirm that you will need to redo the grenade tag kill and knife execution over cover kill again since this update to get them to track. Good point.
0
0
By FiveWizz on 08 Nov 2018 23:32
Dropshot won't count for me either, also stuck at 94%.
0
0
By SEEPAGE ix on 09 Nov 2018 20:13
Dropshot finally registered today and the achievement unlocked. I must've tried 7-8 times with no luck, did a hard reset today and it unlocked after the 1st try.
0
0
By SEEPAGE ix on 09 Nov 2018 21:10
I’m not sure if this happened for anyone else, but I was stuck at 94% and the Tracker said the snub was the only one I didn’t have. I did the execution like 10 times and didn’t get it, then I switched from swarm to Cog and did the Punching execution (the swarm characters to the shoulder smash sort of thing) it only seemed to count when I did the Cog version. Hope that helps if anyone else encounters that.
0
0
By Orbiht on 09 Nov 2018 21:55
View all 41 comments Show less comments
Make the following executions:

• Boomshot
• Buzzkill
• Dropshot
• Embar
• Enforcer
• Gnasher
• Hammerburst
• Meat Shield
• Knife
• Lancer
• Longshot
• Markza
• Mulcher
• Overkill
• Retro Lancer
• Salvo
• Snub
• Torque Bow
• Tri Shot

Check your progress at https://xbltracker.com/ 🔥
51
2
4 Comments
This tool gets better by the minute :), thanks mate
0
0
By EI Bikerboy on 09 Nov 2018 18:17
Such a great tool, thank you!
0
0
By SEEPAGE ix on 09 Nov 2018 21:05
The tracker is very helpful and get the achievement.. Really quick!! Thumb up
0
0
By oakdale7 on 15 Nov 2018 06:31
Awesome tool, heja Sverige! :)
As mentioned in the other solutions' comments, Dropshot was a bit glitchy. I and a buddy both had to do it a couple of times. Keep at it and it'll count eventually.
0
0
By Healtti on 20 Nov 2018 07:44
View all 4 comments Show less comments
I've added tracking for this to my Master at Arms page:
http://24.216.206.219:8001/G4Maa

(if it lists a number of executions you are good, if its blank you dont need that one)

There are 19 executions needed:
17 weapon executions
Boomshot
Buzzkill
Dropshot
Embar
Enforcer
Gnasher
Hammerburst
Lancer
Longshot
Markza
Mulcher
Overkill
Retro Lancer
Salvo
Snub Pistol
Torque Bow
Trishot

2 non-weapon executions
Knife
Neck

Boltok is NOT required
21
2

09 Nov 2018 18:48

Here you go, do this in a private match and follow the video:

14
1

15 Dec 2018 23:26

Judge, Jury and Executioner
You've slayed up in style by performing every unique execution. Inspired by Blowfish666.

You must perform one of every execution. That's all the basic weapons, power weapons, bag and tag with a grenade and a drag-over-cover knife execution. For all of the executions, you will need to down the opponent and then hold cn_Y on their body.

Additionally the achievement can be done in a private game with a second controller. Connect a second controller to your console and press the menu button. Sign in a guest or a second profile. When you go into private play, you'll be COG and your second controller will be swarm.

Weapons:
- Hammerburst
- Lancer
- Gnasher
- Enforcer
- Torque Bow
- Markza
- Boltok
- Dropshot
- Boomshot
- Retro Lancer
- Embar
- Overkill
- Longshot

Power Weapons:
- Mulcher
- Buzzkill
- Tri Shot
- Salvo (the salvo will only show kills in the war journal)
If you're also unsure of which weapons you've done an execution with go into your War Journal and check your weapons. Video guide here:
14
2

18 Nov 2018 06:08