Gorogoa

I can confirm. I wasted an extra 2-3 playthroughs trying to get this. The guide is great. But if you are going for this specific achievement, go into the game settings and erase your saved files for this game. If you try restarting from the first chapter, it won’t unlock

Got dexterity despite some big fuck ups costing me 20 moves or more but not But Why? SO I obviously lost more time than moves during that run.

This doesn't require your data to be deleted, I just let it loop through the credits and started over. As soon as I wasn't trying for speed I was able to get this, even with some mis-clicks I was showing 430 moves when I finished, not sure if the game's count and mine were the same, but I know I had some to spare.

This wouldn't unlock until I deleted the saves as per RossCowan's instructions. Thanks for the heads up.

This absolutely required my data be deleted from everywhere and as soon as I did that I was able to get it to pop. On xbox one o.g. console from 2013

My Xbox One died recently (I've been trying to get a Series X), so I just ended up playing this game on xCloud. This achievement unlocked for me on my second playthrough without having to delete anything. After beating the game the first time, all I did was start a new game by selecting the first chapter.

You can pause the game and it won't count the time. Than follow the video you can get bought trophy.

On PC, I didn't have to delete anything to get these this and "But Why?". Rather than start a new game by selecting the first chapter, I started from the last chapter and finished the game, ran through the credits, and then used the game that started immediately after to get the achievements.

On XBox, I ran multiple playthroughs one right after the other and got “But Why…?” on my third. Just needed the momentum.

I had some trouble unlocking this. Was definitely under 500 several times but no achievement. Quitting to the Home Screen then quitting the game and restarting and it unlocked first time even with a few extra unnecessary moves.

Took me 5 attempts. first attempt got all achievement but this one, the last 4 attempts did every single playthrough the exact same only difference was I force quit the app and started fresh the attempt it finally unlocked. So if you're having the issue where it won't unlock make sure to restart the app upon each new attempt.

For those struggling with Dexterity / Why Me? I got them on additional playthroughs after deleting my save from both the console and cloud and then starting fresh. I got Dexterity first and missed out on Why Me? when I was confident i'd managed under 30, but I deleted my save fully again and timed it out on a 3rd and did it in 25 min and got Why Me? I didn't pause at all on this one.

To delete from the cloud as well as locally:

Manage Game, then down to Saved Data.
Don't press Delete All, highlight your profile then press the Start button (three lines) and then Delete Saved Data.
In here, select Delete Everywhere.

That should be you starting totally fresh and good to go.

How do you know how many moves you have used?

The info in this guide is invaluable. I combined this with the speed run achievement and definitely hit a few extra button presses due to nerves and not paying attention to the cursor icon and pressing buttons early while things were still loading. Following the maka video doesn't emphasise this as it's focused on the speed run. Still got it first try though, even with me screwing up the falling rock puzzle.

Sadly this is not a good video. I just wasted a couple of hours trying to follow your moves. There are to many mistakes in the video. Even then I tried to avoid your mistakes I didn't pop the ach.