Graveyard Keeper

Graveyard Keeper

125 Achievements

2,500

89-118h

Xbox One
Xbox Series
Log in or Register to track Graveyard Keeper achievements progress.
He trusted you...

He trusted you...

Betrayed Gerry. That's not something you should be super-proud of.

30

2.15%

How to unlock the He trusted you... achievement in Graveyard Keeper - Definitive Guide

This is missable

To unlock this you need to progress the Inquisitor questline, this character visits the Witch Hill (location to the east of your house) every Wrath day (the red Mars symbol).

Graveyard KeeperHoly InquisitionThe Holy Inquisition achievement in Graveyard Keeper worth 6 pointsMet the Lord Inquisitor. An unwavering kind of guy. You definitely wouldn't want to be his enemy.


The first steps are pretty straightforward and after a couple of quests you will unlock the buffet tent where you can sell gold-star Burgers and Beer.

Graveyard KeeperNight watchThe Night watch achievement in Graveyard Keeper worth 28 pointsGot rid of the guardsmen's ambush. Now you are the Witch Hill Keeper too!


Graveyard KeeperNot a hot dogThe Not a hot dog achievement in Graveyard Keeper worth 30 pointsSold burgers at the burning ceremony. It's a mystery why you didn't make hotdogs.


After a couple of witch burning he will request 3 Dark organs. After this point you will unlock the relevant skill and those organs will start spawning randomly on new corpses. You need to get a dark brain, heart and intestine to progress.

Graveyard KeeperMatch 3The Match 3 achievement in Graveyard Keeper worth 84 pointsCollected three dark organs. Three in a row! The Inquisition is going to get a prize!


The next week he will tell you that he needs more evidence. At this point you will need to make a choice:

-Tell him about a talking skull (Gerry)
-Tell him about the dark sanctuary beneath the church
-Tell him that you don't know anything

After you pick the first choice you will unlock the achievement.
Graveyard KeeperSecret AchievementThe Secret Achievement achievement in Graveyard Keeper worth 129 pointsContinue playing to unlock this secret achievement


This is a missable achievement since the choice ends the dialogue with the Inquisitor. After this, to finish his questline and get the object for the portal you need to complete
29
1

23 Aug 2018 04:49

9 Comments
Just wanted to add, I finished Snake's ceremony before I gave any of the dark organs to the Inquisitor. You can still visit the Inquisitor on the relevant day afterwards to give him the 3 dark organs, then come back a week later to have the dialog option where you betray Gerry.
0
0
By johnnyjohnathan on 23 Aug 2018 21:50
Thanks for the info! It sounds right considering that the Inquisitor still visits the area after the quest is completed but storywise is weird that he still is doing the investigations after what happens :P
0
0
By Sioul on 29 Aug 2018 15:41
Does something change depending on your choice? I think not, but i better ask. :) So, if one betrays Gerry, is he gone?
0
0
By Tenreth on 29 Aug 2018 23:57
Nothing happens to Gerry if you betray him.
0
0
By I AM CULLY on 31 Aug 2018 04:43
Is there any consequence to choosing to betray him or is it just a random dialog option?
0
0
By Cro11 on 01 Sep 2018 21:16
Just to be perfectly clear: the missable part is choosing the wrong dialogue choice. The option to have the dialogue is still available, even after completing the game. You just have to pick the right choice in the dialogue, otherwise you’ll need to start a new playthrough.
0
0
By WhyattThrash on 06 Apr 2019 09:40
Fucking missable achievement...This game have no replay value...It's not fair...
0
0
By EDUMANILHA on 15 Aug 2019 15:16
Oh nooo! I don't want to betray Gerry!! xD
0
0
By thebritt2001 on 03 Feb 2023 03:22
I had to start a new playthrough after missing this on my original one facepalm. I wanted to point out that after serving burgers and beers a few times I also had to upgrade my church to the cathedral before I could start the dark organs quest. This seems to follow what the wiki details as well https://graveyardkeeper.gamepedia.com/Inquisitor#Convincing_...
0
0
By ZaBetts on 30 Jul 2019 15:17
View all 9 comments Show less comments
This achievement can be missable.

After completing the inquisitor's questline with the 3 dark organs, return to him the next week. He will say he needs more proof of evil and three dialogue options appear. One is to tell him about Gerry, this is the option to choose for the achievement. All options end the conversation and you will miss the opportunity if you dont choose correctly.
0
0

03 Dec 2023 00:00

Near the end of the Inquisitor's path, he'll request you to bring back some other type of proof to help prove to the King why the witch burnings must continue. This will be the end conversation with him before getting the Eternally Burning Coal. He'll ask if you have some proof of dark magic going on around, and you'll have the option to throw Gerry to the Inquisition. Of course, nothing can come of it, as Gerry could easily just clam up. Therefore, nothing more can be exchanged between you and the Inquisitor and it'll seem like that is it (though you still won't be at 100 to get the coal from him). The remaining 10 points come from finishing Snake's questline in the Sacrificial Zone (getting the golden apple, then a dark heart pulled from a corpse).

If you tell the Inquisitor anything else, this is lost to you unless you reload a prior save to this point or replay the entire game.
0
0

05 Sep 2019 04:15

MISSABLE

This is the task "Convincing the Crown" from the Inquisitor's story. You'll be asked to gather three dark organs for him. Get them and return them to him. A week later, you can talk to him and he'll ask if you know of anything else to use as "evidence of witchcraft. Or the undead. Or any other cult stuff". This will give you three different options to pick from. You need to pick the one "I could bring you a talking skull. His name is Gerry".

0
0
When completing the Inquisitor's quest, you will bring him organs. Next time he asks about suspicious things and evidence, choose the answer about Gerry and get a trophy
4
0

12 Jul 2019 15:46

When completing the Inquisitor's quest, you will bring him organs. Next time he asks about suspicious things and evidence, choose the answer about Gerry and get the achievement
1
0

01 Oct 2018 21:44