Horse Tales: Emerald Valley Ranch

If you are anything like me and blaze on through without looking closely, then you would've missed this incredibly easy trophy that can be earned pretty early on. The cat you have to pet is NOT the one down at the harbour. Go to Kiki's tree house, walk all the way to the top and there you should find a tent-like structure with 2 cats. One you can tickle and the other one you can pet.