Library Of Ruina

As with many of the card trick achievements, I don't recommend going for these until you are at the doorstep of the Reverberation Ensemble so that you'll have proper tools.

As always, there are likely multiple solutions to this, this is mine and it worked for me so hooray for things.

I used the floor of Natural Sciences and I did a solo run against the puppets with a librarian on the Olivier page with the passives of Lyla & Walter for the +1 defense die, Mi for Puffy Brume & Stimulating Fumes, and then Yae for smoke overflow, but that last one could probably be something better.

The deck layout is fairly simple:
2 Smoking Pipe
3 Inhale Smoke
3 Bi An (Because of the accent characters this won't search well)
1 Serpentine Barrier

The name of the game is block like a madman. Once you stagger a puppet from the shield, punch them with an inhale smoke. Two shots should get them down to around 7-10 health. With Bi An drawing cards, you'll have a near infinite engine. With the abnormality page "Love", you'll also win back stagger damage you might have lost from one-sided attacks sneaking in. Road to Happiness will also keep you in good form in case anything sneaks in late game.

You want to get to the point where the bulk of the puppets are staggered (which, at 4 dice available in higher emotions, is plausible), then make sure to choose the EGO page "In The Name of Love & Hate" which is a big 22-33 blunt mass attack. All 5 should crumble and a winner is you. Like the other conditional achievements, this should pop upon killing the five, no need to wait for the end of the match.