Life is Strange: True Colors

Once you've entered "The Black Lantern", you'll automatically speak with Duckie, who's made himself comfortable behind the bar. After your conversation is over, head towards the back area of the bar where the pool table, the giant bear statue and dart boards are located. As you enter, look left and you'll see the "Old Paper" that you'll need to interact with resting on a table. Hold "LT" and then the "A" button, listen to the memory play out and the achievement will pop!