Madden NFL 09

Video i found for SYNNESTER R I P solution (this should work for both punt and TD returns)

on rookie. when you recieve the ball run down one side of the pitch when you getting close to the opposition players turn round and run backwards a few yards. Run to the other wing in a straight line when there turn round run backwards. Run to the original wig by now thier entire team is behind you and you can run straight up the wing for a touch down. this can also be used to return the kickoffs.

With two controllers I played as the Patriots with the controller I was trying to get the achievement with (1), and with the other (2) I picked the Falcons. Rookie difficulty and unlimited rewinds in case i made a mistake.

I'll number the steps to make it easier to read.

1) Pick heads or tails
2) Make sure Controller 2 is the receiver and Controller 1 is the kicker
3) Kick the ball and run into the opposition with controller 2 once you've caught it
4) Pick any formation
5) With controller 1, tackle the player with the ball once he's hiked it (Don't pass. If you did, allow yourself to get tackled and use a rewind) Keep doing this until the option to punt it come up.
6) Fully charge the punt and hold down on controller 2s left analog stick while tapping B. And with controller 1, sprint around the opposition easily and score the touch down.
[If you didn't score repeat step 5 with the other controller then redo step 5)
7) Score the field goal and kick the ball back to the opposition. Then repeat step 1 onward until you reach 2 TD Punt returns.

To make sure you have the 2 TD Punt returns,
Press Pause > Game Stats > Hold RT and scroll up to Punt Return > Scroll across to "TD"
Once you have confirmed you have the required number,you can then quit the match and the achievement will pop up.

Solution feedback is appreciated :)

I did this one and the 2 kickoff TD return achievements today in about 5 minutes. I played a 2 player game with my son, he kicked the ball off to me and as I ran up the field he just kept switching control to different players on the field and made them dive in the opposite direction. He then quickly scored and did the same again. Then we did the same thing for the punt returns. After I got 2 of each I just turned off the play clock and took a knee a few times till the end of the game.

Also remember that safety punts do not count. After you get the 2 TD returns for Punts, you can easily rundown the clock by turning off the Play Clock and and using QB Kneel.