Middle-earth: Shadow of War

***New Update to the game that removed micro-transactions also allows you to turn off "Saviors". In the menus, turn off the setting to "Allow Saviors" and you will have no problem nabbing this anymore. Just follow the guide below. I will cross-out the details you don't need but leave them to show you the original solution and the pain the rest of us went through!***

In Act II, You will quickly gain the ability to dominate Captains from one of the first story missions. Once you have this ability, you can potentially get this achievement.

Let a random orc kill you ONCE to be promoted, and a SECOND time as Captain. There will be a good chance that the THIRD time he kills you he will already be a Warchief or get promoted to one so be ready to perform some requirements to draw him out. Also be aware that when you see him for the 4th time, he will likely be too high of a level to be dominated and added to your army, you will need to dominate him and follow the prompts to Shame him ( after dominating him, to lower his level), and then you will need to probably find him a 5th time to get this achievement.

ORIGINAL SOLUTION:

Simply letting a Captain kill you a few times and then dominating him would pretty straightforward if it wasn't for the game babying you and having another Orc intervene when you are being killed. One of your dominated Captains or an unknown "Random Savior" will swoop in and kill the Captain who is executing you. This happens much more frequently than you would like when you are trying to die. To combat this, I recommend bumping up the difficulty to Gravewalker. This means the Captain should kill you in one or two hits and you can die very easily from others so be careful. Once you have bumped up the difficulty, let a random orc kill you ONCE to be promoted, and a SECOND time as Captain. There will be a good chance that the THIRD time he kills you he will already be a Warchief or get promoted to one so be ready to perform some requirements to draw him out. Once the orc has killed you 3 times, lets abuse the difficulty settings one more time and set it to Easy just to be sure you have complete control of the situation when you hunt him again. Also be aware that when you see him for the 4th time, he will likely be too high of a level to be dominated and added to your army, you will need to dominate him and follow the prompts to Shame him ( after dominating him, to lower his level), and then you will need to probably find him a 5th time to get this achievement.

After you pop the achievement by dominating him (), feel free to put the difficulty back to Normal or whatever mode you like. Please keep in mind that even on Gravewalker, I had my execution by an orc interrupted by a Random Savior, but it was much less likely. I was saved on Normal every time (maybe 8 in a row), and then when I bumped up the difficulty, I was saved on Gravewalker once in around 5 times being executed. Trying to die in a video game should not be this hard!

*If this solution helped you in some way, please vote positively. If you think it needs improvement, please let me know how in a private message or by leaving a comment.*

Pretty self-explanatory. You can't dominate an orc until Act II, but you can have them kill you any time. After killing you, they get significantly stronger, so you might have to humiliate him after he's killed you all three times.

Also, I'm not sure how the game determines whether the orc will humiliate you or kill you, but it seems that each orc is predisposed toward one or the other. If you get down to your last chance and the orc chooses to humiliate you rather than kill you, then they'll most likely keep doing the same thing every time. Find an orc who chooses to kill you outright rather than trying to get one to change its tune.

The previous solutions give a lot of good advice, but this achievement just got a lot easier since the latest update that mainly included the removal of the market. The update also included a new setting in the game options called "allow saviors". Untick the checkbox there and you won't have any more trouble getting "saved" before someone kills you.

As others already stated you just have to wait until Act II, where you get the ability to dominate captains. Just get killed by a random orc and find him again. He will be promoted to captain. There is a high chance that he gets promoted to warchief when he kills you again, so you have to lure him out and shame him to decrease his level. If you don't do that he might just become overlord, making the whole process very difficult to handle. Get through a few cycles of getting killed and shaming the guy afterwards until you got killed three times.

After having been killed for the third time the captain/warchief may have a higher level than you have, so dominating him is not possible anymore since you need to have at least the same or a higher level to be able to this. If that happens to you too you have to level up a bit before you start the last quest to dominate him. Leveling up also got easier with the patch, because killing random captains now provides a lot more XP than before.