MLB The Show 24

Start a road to the show character who plays centre field. During game 2 of the draft combine it had me set up for a pop fly catch and throw to third base. If this doesnt play out keep loading a new character until you get the aformentioned setup. Being player locked doesn't effect the achievement at all if you do decide to try this in classic. As a word of warning as well I found that lots of achievements will only pop 1 per game played. I don't reccomend playing this game using the quick resume feature

Edit: there is a mini game after pressing the base throwing button. There's like 2 or 3 different things that will pop up so keep on your toes and expect to have a slow motion aim or qte event after throwing to the correct base