NCAA Football 10
47 Achievements
1,000
10-12h
Can You Believe It?
Return a missed field goal for a touchdown in Exhibition or Dynasty Mode (excludes co-op).
25
How to unlock the Can You Believe It? achievement in NCAA Football 10 - Definitive Guide
Start playing the game, let controller 2 receive the ball. For the 1st play pick special teams and field goal. Let controller 1 pick special teams and punt return. Now with player one, pick the punt returner and move him about 40-50 yards from the line of scrimage so he can actually catch the ball. Put down controller 1. Let the computer control him. With controller 2 kick the fieldgoal with close to full power. What will (should) happen is the punt returner will catch the ball and automatically run towards the endzone.
With controller 2, quickly alternate pressing B and X, ie BXBXBXBXBXBXBXBXBXBXBXBXBXBXB etc. This select player (B)(usually the one closest to the ball) and forces him to dive(X). The CPU will take the punt returner to end zone and achievement unlocks.
This can be done with other achievements (take interception back for touchdown, kickoff or punt return for TD, break 50 yard run, etc, etc). If you make a mistake, just punt the ball back and try again.
This one you'll have to do with a second player or a second controller. The reason is that the computer very rarely goes for a field goal that is well out of the kicker's range. You'll want to set the kicking team up around mid-field. They'll choose Field Goal from the Special Teams plays. As the team on defense, you'll go to Special Teams and choose Field Goal Block Return. You'll notice there will be a CB standing in the endzone. The kicking team will try for the field goal like normal, except that it'll be well short. As the ball is coming down, the CB will run up, catch it, and start his return. All you have to do is avoid the players on the kicking team. Your player will be pretty fast, so it's not too hard. Although, you may want to play on Freshman or Varsity to make it easier.
Note: If the field goal attempt touches the ground, the play is dead and you can't return the ball.