Pick your player as ROLB (coverage) and QB (balanced). Make your player 7'0" (all the better to block with). Wait till 4th down, position yourself in front of the punter (not too close, but not so close to the center that another player picks up your blitz) and SPAM the LB button to swat it down. Hopefully you should get it.
I tried MLB, I tried FS, I tried CB, I tried just about every defensive position. I simmed about 50 games. I even had a game where I watched FOUR of my teammates get defensive TDs. Nothing worked.
Here's what did. Seeing that the QB typically throws outside instead of over the middle, I picked ROLB (first position, coverage), hoping for INTs. I got a couple while simming, but no TDs.
So I started actually playing the defensive plays and simming the offense. (My secondary position was QB, balanced, and I got plenty of TDs as QB.) What I found was that I almost ALWAYS got put on punt return. Even in series where I was skipped over for other downs, on 4th down I still found myself on punt duty. Perfect. After a few punts, blocking two of them but not recovering them, I was finally able to scoop one in for the TD.
This achievement ticked me off so much. I played it basically for 3 days trying for this last cheeve for 1k. I hope you can do better. :-)
Edit: Just for reference, the achievement will not pop until the end of the game, so you're going to have to sweat it out if you think you've gotten the 2 TDs. Best of luck!
37 Comments
Worked perfectly; got it within four games of trying. Thanks a ton!
By fuzzyjw510 on 09 Aug 2011 21:38
Thanks for the tips Sasha. Once I figure out how to block punts it worked like a charm. I would like to add to make sure to do it outside of their 10 yard line, or they go into a formation with more people around the punter.
By Shinwasha on 15 Aug 2011 02:42
I was actually able to sim with my QB on offensive plays and get TDs that way. I only went in during 4th down punt plays, so I guess the sim gave me better opportunities for TDs.
By Sashamorning on 21 Aug 2011 21:22
Accidentally deleted my comment. In response to the above, when I tried using the ROLB / QB method, for whatever reason the achievement didn't unlock even though I had been credited with an offensive touchdown while simming?
Still, excellent strategy - thumbs up!
By MartyO on 21 Aug 2011 21:32
Now that's weird. :-(. And it's weird. I've never had a problem scoring as a QB, either thowing or running.
By Sashamorning on 21 Aug 2011 22:01
Any idea if playing on a low difficulty, or if simming out the rest of the game after you've scored both offensive and defensive TDs affects this? I played the game on freshman, threw and rushed for a TD, and recovered a blocked punt for a TD, and unfortunately, no cheeve :(. Any thoughts?
By Mortis Invictus on 28 Sep 2011 00:24
I just got it; I did up the difficulty to Varsity, but honestly, it wouldn't surprise me if the cheeve just didn't decide to work last game. At any rate, fantastic guide. +1!
By Mortis Invictus on 28 Sep 2011 15:22
Glad you got it! :-) Like I said, this thing was a pain for me, too.
By Sashamorning on 28 Sep 2011 17:10
Is there a trick to blocking punts? I'm able to get out and stand near the punter but he knocks me over or i tackle him. Thanks!
By savesheep on 29 Sep 2011 02:45
It's tricky. Run up as he's in the motion and SPAM the LB. Just keep trying. It took me a bunch of times.
By Sashamorning on 29 Sep 2011 03:02
Great guide! I did find out though that you can use the Y button also. It was easier to me using Y.
By GeauxTigersMatt on 13 Oct 2011 08:45
great tip. best way to go IMO. Key i found for me was standing directly behind the long snapper because when id run at the punter at an angle I would swat it but somebody would always get it, then I ran straight and swatted it to the endzone for the easy 1k achievement. Thanks!
By FAH fl0p on 22 Nov 2011 06:11
Nice guide. I've done this 4 times though on Varsity, and All american and still haven't got the achievement. None of the TDs were simulated. Seriously getting pissed off now. Might delete my save because this same thing happened with ncaa 2008..
By Hashmap on 12 Dec 2011 04:56
This is by far the best solution. I tried every thing out there many, many times and had zero luck. I did it this method and in the first game I got two scoop and scores as my ROLB on punt return. Remember to adjust the sliders and turn off offsides and I adjusted the CPU Tackling and Punt Power (hit LT to change from USER) to zero.
By CincyMon on 01 Jan 2012 14:47
I hate this damn achievement it is purely luck based even if you are cheating.
By tsetse f1y on 17 Apr 2012 01:49
By Sashamorning on 18 Apr 2012 00:53
I got very very lucky with this achievement. I was following your guide, and after probably 4 games, I happened to return an interception while simming. Then I just made it downfield and threw a touchdown. Also, the achievement didn't pop until the game was over, so don't freak out :)
By tarling on 24 Mar 2012 22:29
Great solution, was never on punt block as a CB in my previous RTG, but as a ROLB was on punt block, and 2nd punt I was in for the opposing punter lined up in the endzone, I hit him, he coughed up the ball, I scored, and then I wished I could teabag him :-p
By spxyu02 on 13 May 2012 15:53
Awesome guide... got it in my very first game trying! Thanks man!
By ner69 on 28 Jun 2012 04:03
Okay. What the hell. I scored 2 rushing TD's and 2 safetys. Do safety's not count or something????
By SollyBearsif on 26 Oct 2012 03:32
Wow. No, only TDs, which is why this sucks so hard.
By Sashamorning on 26 Oct 2012 03:41
Nevermind. Got it. Lol
I got a TD and at literally the last second, blocked a punt and picked it up right in the endzone.
+1 for you, thanks!
By SollyBearsif on 26 Oct 2012 03:47
I blocked the punt with Y not LB as I found it easier if that helps anyone
By mudder85 on 14 Dec 2012 19:03
I have done this three times and the achievement wont pop
By MadTrav on 02 Mar 2013 09:42
You actually scored the TD on defense and it didn't pop? That's annoying. This is already the most annoying achievement in the entire game.
By Sashamorning on 02 Mar 2013 11:13
No TD was simulated, I physically completed each one and it was 3 rushing tds, not two
By MadTrav on 02 Mar 2013 14:42
i just had a fumble for a td and 3 qb tds, didnt pop, not cool, i thought wow first game and everything, guess ill keep trying.
By Lancebond7 on 06 May 2013 22:22
It is SUCH a bitch. Think it might be buggy, but... I dunno. Just keep at it!
By Sashamorning on 06 May 2013 23:34
Got it first try thanks to you. May want to mention it unlocks after the game though.
By BadTriangle on 17 May 2013 21:04
By Sashamorning on 19 May 2013 02:17
Awesome, thanks! Got it first game, right near the end of the 4th quarter. Knocked down a couple earlier, but couldn't get to them, then finally had a perfect one straight behind the punter. Scooped it up at about the 10 and just got in before being tackled. 8)
By Buckswana on 01 Sep 2013 18:33
This is such a frustrating achievement typical of EA. The camera angle they give you is beyond bad it makes Resident Evil look like Leon Shamroy shot it
By Steve Redman on 20 Jul 2015 14:10
Worked perfectly, got it on the first try thanks! Not sure why anyone is voting negative....
By JJ DANG3R on 17 Mar 2017 12:51
By Sashamorning on 17 Mar 2017 18:48
I blocked a punt for a TD and scored on offense and no achievement WTF
By xIt5Mill3rTim3x on 20 Dec 2019 16:33
Worked like a charm, got it 2nd game after i got used to the angle the punt camera is in. actually ended up with 3 defencive TD's using this. the key is to have it bouce off your chest and go 5 yards or so away from the punter, otherwise someone on the punt team might get to it and just be a safety instead.
By NickHawkeye on 30 Apr 2012 16:01
Can someone please tell me what I am doing wrong. This is the 6th game that I have an offensive and defensive TD in the same game and no cheevo. I have tried deleting all previous save files and starting from scratch. My last game I had two rushing TD's (HB) and two Def TD from forced fumbles, i blocked punt and 1 QB fumble. Still nothing popped. I have it on varsity difficulty, have not changed any options except offsides. Help please?
By MadTrav on 02 Mar 2013 14:40