Paradise Killer

Straightforward. Spam Sam Day Break's Hangout dialog option until you get an achievement and the dialog is grayed and says maxed out. You can either Hangout every time you see them or simply wait 2-3 minutes in front of them and then speak again to allow you to choose the dialog again. The choices you make don't effect the outcome so you can just button mash through it. If they are going to give you a Probe option or a gift, they will regardless of how the Hangout conversations turn out.