Red Dead Redemption 2
51 Achievements
PC
All's Fair
Red Dead Online: You successfully countered a rival Posse's Free Roam mission.
How to unlock the All's Fair achievement in Red Dead Redemption 2 - Definitive Guide
In free roam you occasionally will see a message pop up on screen letting you know that a rival posse has stolen a wagon/money bags a prison coach or something of the sort. When you see this message go and intercept said scenario, kill the rival members if you need to and most importantly steal the money bags or wagon and deliver them to the location on your map or destroy the wagon if that is what it tells you to do. Once the mission is complete all members of the posse will unlock the achievement.
If you so wish you can boost this with ONE other player. Have both players form a posse and have turns starting a free roam mission whereby you intercept a wagon and steal the money bags/wagon or any mission that offers kidnaps, mail bags, Wagon recovery or horse thefts. To do this have one person start the mission and go collect what they are told to and then simply have the person going for the achievement waiting nearby or following behind and have them swoop in and intercept the mission, it will get them to either destroy the wagon or deliver it; Note only do this after the message pops up saying "you can rival a posses mission" and pops up on the other players screen saying"A Rival posse can steal the wagon/horse etc"
The mission just east of Armadillo at MACFARLANE`S RANCH with Bonnie is ideal to boost this, or any mission that offers kidnaps, mail bags, Wagon recovery or horse thefts.
PLEASE NOTE: The mission with the canoes does not work for this achievement nor do the hunting missions.
Alternatively you can attain this achievement if you are targeted as an assassination and you escape, Thank you to Yurgi Windu in the comments for that information.
Thank you
If you so wish you can boost this with ONE other player. Have both players form a posse and have turns starting a free roam mission whereby you intercept a wagon and steal the money bags/wagon or any mission that offers kidnaps, mail bags, Wagon recovery or horse thefts. To do this have one person start the mission and go collect what they are told to and then simply have the person going for the achievement waiting nearby or following behind and have them swoop in and intercept the mission, it will get them to either destroy the wagon or deliver it; Note only do this after the message pops up saying "you can rival a posses mission" and pops up on the other players screen saying"A Rival posse can steal the wagon/horse etc"
The mission just east of Armadillo at MACFARLANE`S RANCH with Bonnie is ideal to boost this, or any mission that offers kidnaps, mail bags, Wagon recovery or horse thefts.
PLEASE NOTE: The mission with the canoes does not work for this achievement nor do the hunting missions.
Alternatively you can attain this achievement if you are targeted as an assassination and you escape, Thank you to Yurgi Windu in the comments for that information.
Thank you
172 Comments
Looking to boost, GT: Markavellli
By Markavellli on 14 Sep 2019 15:59
I need people for this every posse i join is just messing around and teamkilling
By N1klas1997 on 03 Dec 2018 22:05
For anyone who plays solo or does not feel like boosting, I have some tips! Though it will still involve a bit of luck.
-Make sure you have Dynamite or Fire Bottles in your inventory!
-I played a lot in Free Roam around Scarlet Meadows (the area around Rhodes). Note that there is a Free Roam mission the requires the player to bring 1 or 2 wagons to the mansion at Braithwaite Manor. The luck involves another player doing this mission while you are in the area!
-If you see a blue dot (another online player) traveling on a wagon (with possibly another behind them) on a road leading to Braithwaite Manor then odds are they are doing this mission.
-Follow behind them until they reach the long straight road south to the mansion. When they reach that road it should say "Attack another Player's Free Roam Mission"
-At this point, don't bother shooting the player or horses. Just equip your dynamite or fire bottles and toss 2-3 at one of the wagons. As long as you destroy at least one of the wagons the achievement should unlock (even if the player delivers the other one)!
The dynamite method should work for any delivery mission but I found that the delivery mission by Braithwaite Manor seemed to be most striaghtforward (literally) for others still struggling with this achievement.
There is some good hunting (boars, deer, coyotes) and easy access to shops in Rhodes if you set up camp in Scarlet Meadows and are waiting around trying your luck out at this. Best of luck!
-Make sure you have Dynamite or Fire Bottles in your inventory!
-I played a lot in Free Roam around Scarlet Meadows (the area around Rhodes). Note that there is a Free Roam mission the requires the player to bring 1 or 2 wagons to the mansion at Braithwaite Manor. The luck involves another player doing this mission while you are in the area!
-If you see a blue dot (another online player) traveling on a wagon (with possibly another behind them) on a road leading to Braithwaite Manor then odds are they are doing this mission.
-Follow behind them until they reach the long straight road south to the mansion. When they reach that road it should say "Attack another Player's Free Roam Mission"
-At this point, don't bother shooting the player or horses. Just equip your dynamite or fire bottles and toss 2-3 at one of the wagons. As long as you destroy at least one of the wagons the achievement should unlock (even if the player delivers the other one)!
The dynamite method should work for any delivery mission but I found that the delivery mission by Braithwaite Manor seemed to be most striaghtforward (literally) for others still struggling with this achievement.
There is some good hunting (boars, deer, coyotes) and easy access to shops in Rhodes if you set up camp in Scarlet Meadows and are waiting around trying your luck out at this. Best of luck!
2 Comments
Please Me Help Red Dead Redemption 2 Achievement
By TheRetroVHS on 20 Nov 2019 04:08
My tag is “WoozyIvy1049462”
By WoozyIvy1049462 on 05 Aug 2020 22:27
To earn the All's Fair trophy in Red Dead Online, you simply need to thwart another player or team's attempt to complete a Free Roam mission -- i.e. a non-story mission that takes place in the shared world with all players.
The easiest mission to counter is a stagecoach robbery, which will appear as a red reticle on a black circle background on the mini-map. Head over and deal with whoever is in the area, which may still be the original NPCs or may be a group of players (hopefully you catch them off guard in these early days, and it's just the one guy).
In the early game you may not have anything to destroy the coach with efficiently such as dynamite. Your best bet is to kill or free the horses, drive the whole thing off a cliff or, my method, drive it into the deep part of a river, lake or the sea. The horses will be freed and the stagecoach technically destroyed.
The easiest mission to counter is a stagecoach robbery, which will appear as a red reticle on a black circle background on the mini-map. Head over and deal with whoever is in the area, which may still be the original NPCs or may be a group of players (hopefully you catch them off guard in these early days, and it's just the one guy).
In the early game you may not have anything to destroy the coach with efficiently such as dynamite. Your best bet is to kill or free the horses, drive the whole thing off a cliff or, my method, drive it into the deep part of a river, lake or the sea. The horses will be freed and the stagecoach technically destroyed.
8 Comments
Anyone willing to help? If yes, PM me, my PSN: GampxS
By GampxS on 02 Aug 2019 10:45
I just learned a key bit of information for this one. If you are playing in Defensive mode, you will not be offered the option to counter a rival posse. It tells you to come out of Defensive mode to get the counter option, but you then have to wait 30 seconds for that to happen which could make it too late.
So when looking for this, always use Offensive mode
So when looking for this, always use Offensive mode
By BeardedScot86 on 05 Mar 2020 10:32
This one can easily be boosted with two players.
Start an online free roam session then invite a friend or have him/her join your session. Have each person create their own posse (set it to private). Ride to a mission that is far away from all the other players in the server so that they won't interfere. The person that is not going for the trophy starts the mission (delivery missions are the easiest to do). As soon as the message "Rival players can now counter your mission" appears tell that to your partner so that he/she can counter your mission. When the mission fails the other person should get the trophy.
Another easy method is to utilise the free Roam missions where the objective is to assassinate a player. If you are ever the target of one of this missions leave what you are doing, open your map and see where the rival player is coming from (red player on the map), put a waypoint on the opposite side the rival is coming from and start riding your horse until the timer expires, it will cause the other player's mission to fail and give you the trophy.
[Credit to Jvaferreria]
Start an online free roam session then invite a friend or have him/her join your session. Have each person create their own posse (set it to private). Ride to a mission that is far away from all the other players in the server so that they won't interfere. The person that is not going for the trophy starts the mission (delivery missions are the easiest to do). As soon as the message "Rival players can now counter your mission" appears tell that to your partner so that he/she can counter your mission. When the mission fails the other person should get the trophy.
Another easy method is to utilise the free Roam missions where the objective is to assassinate a player. If you are ever the target of one of this missions leave what you are doing, open your map and see where the rival player is coming from (red player on the map), put a waypoint on the opposite side the rival is coming from and start riding your horse until the timer expires, it will cause the other player's mission to fail and give you the trophy.
[Credit to Jvaferreria]
This guide was translated automatically.
Just show up for another gang's mission and shoot everyone. There must be a squad of enemies. The easiest way is to come to clear the lair.
12 Comments
It is easiest to perform when the enemy unit is carrying a stagecoach. Take dynamite (often found when searching corpses) and throw it under the wheels. I completed this trophy purely by accident.
By BryukBond on 12 Dec 2018 14:27
After the summer 2020 patch, players began to take on missions from strangers much less often, and it became much more difficult to intercept the mission of someone else’s squad. I knocked it out like this: I found a dude on Facebook, agreed with him for a while, went into his session, we both went into our own squad (for this trophy you both need to be members of warring permanent squads), I shot him for enmity, he was reborn and took on a mission (to steal a horse and drive it to Saint-Denis), I shot him again)), got on the stolen horse and drove it to the indicated place. The trophy is mine. I can't imagine how you can get it yourself.
By toha_toha on 31 Jan 2021 15:24
This guide was translated automatically.
Got a trophy when I was targeted by another player. I just ran from him and killed him. Survived 10 minutes and received the trophy.
We cannot show the content due to copyright protection. Please click the link below to view the guide.