Red Dead Redemption 2

Red Dead Redemption 2

51 Achievements

Xbox One
Log in or Register to track Red Dead Redemption 2 achievements progress.
All's Fair

All's Fair

Red Dead Online: You successfully countered a rival Posse's Free Roam mission.

How to unlock the All's Fair achievement in Red Dead Redemption 2 - Definitive Guide

In free roam you occasionally will see a message pop up on screen letting you know that a rival posse has stolen a wagon/money bags a prison coach or something of the sort. When you see this message go and intercept said scenario, kill the rival members if you need to and most importantly steal the money bags or wagon and deliver them to the location on your map or destroy the wagon if that is what it tells you to do. Once the mission is complete all members of the posse will unlock the achievement.

If you so wish you can boost this with ONE other player. Have both players form a posse and have turns starting a free roam mission whereby you intercept a wagon and steal the money bags/wagon or any mission that offers kidnaps, mail bags, Wagon recovery or horse thefts. To do this have one person start the mission and go collect what they are told to and then simply have the person going for the achievement waiting nearby or following behind and have them swoop in and intercept the mission, it will get them to either destroy the wagon or deliver it; Note only do this after the message pops up saying "you can rival a posses mission" and pops up on the other players screen saying"A Rival posse can steal the wagon/horse etc"

The mission just east of Armadillo at MACFARLANE`S RANCH with Bonnie is ideal to boost this, or any mission that offers kidnaps, mail bags, Wagon recovery or horse thefts.

PLEASE NOTE: The mission with the canoes does not work for this achievement nor do the hunting missions.

Alternatively you can attain this achievement if you are targeted as an assassination and you escape, Thank you to Yurgi Windu in the comments for that information.

Thank you
72
8

29 Nov 2018 13:31

172 Comments
Looking to boost, GT: Markavellli
0
0
By Markavellli on 14 Sep 2019 15:59
I need people for this every posse i join is just messing around and teamkilling
0
0
By N1klas1997 on 03 Dec 2018 22:05
That can be arranged, I will message you when I am next on the box if you do not get it before then
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 04 Dec 2018 09:00
I do not longer need help thanks!
0
0
By N1klas1997 on 06 Dec 2018 22:13
I was going to boost this, but a friend driving a wagon we all decided to ride in crashed into someone else trying to steal a wagon. Shooting started, and I kill the horses before I got killed and it completed and the achievement popped.
0
0
By Fuzzmeister J on 07 Dec 2018 18:02
I got this by just avoiding an assassination that another posse had marked me for. Survived the 5 minutes and it popped right after the time finished.
0
0
By Yurgi Windu on 13 Dec 2018 11:45
Good to know, I shall add it. Thank you.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 13 Dec 2018 12:19
@Zeman1 message me on xbox when you are next on and we can do that for you.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 15 Dec 2018 18:28
Somebody want to boost it? Add me :)
Got it, thank You @Petrolium Bear :)
0
0
By Zeman1 on 16 Dec 2018 05:46
If anybody wants to boost this one real quick add me :)
GT andre171
0
0
By andre171 on 17 Dec 2018 03:21
I need this too so feel free to get in touch.
0
0
By Calex dEUS on 22 Dec 2018 00:06
Gt LanceX2

I need this 2
0
0
By LanceX2 on 13 Jan 2019 19:01
Anyone mind helping me boost this achievement?
0
0
By Galenrandir on 04 Mar 2019 22:25
I don't mind I will be on tomorrow from 14:00 GMT 00.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 05 Mar 2019 00:18
Thank you so much! I’ll be on around that time!
0
0
By Galenrandir on 05 Mar 2019 02:20
I got this randomly in Rhodes. Basically the stranger mission there involves the posse moving bags to designated spots. So all you have to do is grab one of the bags (while the posse are far away delivering the other ones) and drop it off yourself.
Also you don't need to be in a posse to get the achievement I found.
0
0
By Lockie on 09 Mar 2019 05:55
Thank you for the information Lockie.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 09 Mar 2019 09:33
I play solo and feel like I'll never get this. Anyone wanna help a loner out? GT: MERKgruber4. I'll be on all weekend probably.
0
0
By MERKgruber4 on 15 Mar 2019 17:40
I will be on tonight and most of the weekend so hit me up with a message when you are on.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 15 Mar 2019 19:51
Nevermind! Got it by swiping a mailbag randomly and barely delivering it. Annoying achievement for me.
0
0
By MERKgruber4 on 16 Mar 2019 05:38
If anybody wants to boost this, hit me up.
0
0
By CKY Kraid on 20 Apr 2019 14:32
Hello. someone is interested in bostering all’s fair?
updating: unlocked today
0
0
By Franco3188 on 03 May 2019 17:49
Hey Franco3188, I will help you on Saturday if you have not got it by then.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 03 May 2019 19:30
Send me a message on Xbox if you are looking for another player to do this with. Can use party chat or no chat, not fussed. Just need this achievement.
Gamertag: Carbonitex
0
0
By Carbonitex on 13 May 2019 12:52
the key to this is being far away from the other player. once you get the pop up of "rival players can steal this wagon" meet up and get it that way you'll know you did it right when you can't see your boosting partner near you until they're basically right beside you.
0
0
By TheAaronLad on 25 May 2019 01:17
Hi.
I need help with this one :)
0
0
By Lord Hektor on 01 Jun 2019 21:10
Need a Hand with this one ,gamertag is theportlyhunter
0
0
By HappySoyBoy on 13 Jun 2019 03:04
Need. Gametag: Berriartua
0
0
By Berriartua on 19 Jun 2019 20:53
Looking for help, live in N. America. Gamertag: ToastiestCape0
0
0
By ToastiestCape0 on 26 Jun 2019 17:41
Add me to boost this
GT: ShadyTomb
0
0
By ShadyTomb on 09 Jul 2019 18:35
Looking to boost this with someone. Just send me a message if I’m showing offline. Gamer tag: FAT BRADKID.

Thanks in advance!
0
0
By l BradKid l on 19 Jul 2019 22:41
Looking to boost this with someone. Just send me a message if I’m showing offline. Gamer tag: FAT BRADKID.

Thanks in advance!
0
0
By l BradKid l on 19 Jul 2019 22:43
Looking to boost this. GT KDolez
0
0
By KDolez on 03 Aug 2019 18:45
Anyone willing to help me boost the achievement? I’ll happily boost back if you don’t have it as payment. Gamertag: Hayden247#1498

Edit: me and some other guy who saw this boosted it so I now have the achievement, if you need help with this achievement I’ll happily help out though
0
0
By Hayden2447 on 08 Nov 2021 10:59
Has anyone heard of this cool new feature?
https://www.trueachievements.com/creategamingsession.aspx?ga...
0
0
By MasterMinshew on 15 Sep 2019 06:14
Jeffer Steven65
0
0
By jeffer steven65 on 04 Aug 2019 16:43
Does someone still need this? My tag is
I Stic12 I
0
0
By I Stic12 I on 18 Aug 2019 18:34
anyone looking to boost this lemme know :)
0
0
By xIImiseryIIx on 13 Sep 2019 01:44
Looking to do this

Gt: Robbie ivelja
0
0
By robbie ivelja on 02 Nov 2019 18:58
If anyone still require this or just help me for this
GT: ANGERAN
0
0
By ANGERAN on 08 Nov 2019 12:52
If anyone is willing to boost this, I'm up for it. GT: Ra1D3nHUN
0
0
By Ra1D3nHUN on 20 Nov 2019 08:07
Looking to do this achievement
GT: Huwscor2
0
0
By Huwscor2 on 06 Dec 2019 22:09
Can anyone help with this achievement :)? my GT is: Gonciar

Thanks!
0
0
By Gonciar on 22 Dec 2019 15:42
Anyone need help with this? GT is TengleR13
0
0
By TengleR13 on 02 Feb 2020 18:35
Would someone mind giving me a hand with this achievement? It’s the last MP one I need?
0
0
By Mark Doran on 09 Feb 2020 09:05
If anyone still needs this let me know.
0
0
By BadTriangle on 14 Feb 2020 22:44
Does anyone still want this as it's the last achievement I need? GT: AbnormalCrane12
0
0
By AbnormalCrane12 on 26 Feb 2020 17:13
Looking to get this one gt: baz0oka b0mb
0
0
By baz0oka b0mb on 27 Feb 2020 05:37
@AbnormalCrane12 I can help any evening from 6pm, shoot me a message on Xbox when suits. You too Bazooka;)
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 27 Feb 2020 08:29
Anyone want to do this with me? I play nights starting at 10-11 PM (-8:00 PST). I may also be open earlier on Saturday night this weekend.
0
0
By RealistIdealist on 27 Feb 2020 18:12
Hey Realistdealist, I can do that tomorrow night your time, Saturday morning for me.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 27 Feb 2020 18:32
Hit me up, i got some time tommorow from around 2PM (GMT+1) and could really use the help
0
0
By TheOnlyFodi on 27 Feb 2020 21:51
Aw heck I missed that comment. My bad. I'm still open most nights starting 10-11 PM PST. Can do almost any day of the week.
0
0
By RealistIdealist on 02 Mar 2020 17:13
If you want to do this achievement on Xbox than add FreestylePaul and send me a message. I'll be having some time now since school is cancelled because of corona. I also need the Strength in Numbers achievement so I want to do that one as well.
0
0
By FreestylePaul on 13 Mar 2020 11:54
Hey Paul, I can help. I will be on today so shoot me a message on xbox if you want to do this.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 13 Mar 2020 16:12
Anyone who needs help with this, I’m keen, just send me a message on live, take note I’m in NZ
0
0
By HitchyNZ on 17 Mar 2020 05:20
I need help getting this achievement
0
0
By Wozarnator W800 on 22 Mar 2020 12:10
Also need this, send me a message on live to Sir Lagselot.

Edit: Thanks to the TA community I was able to get this achievement. No longer need help, but thank you.
0
0
By Sir Lagselot on 31 Mar 2020 16:36
I need this as well, willing to boost. Send message to thommaso
0
0
By thommaso on 11 Apr 2020 07:29
Need to boost, message me to T3OR Jäger
0
0
By T3OR Jäger on 12 Apr 2020 01:21
I need this one as well, message me on XBL!
0
0
By The Good Caleb on 13 Apr 2020 19:35
Anyone willing to boost this one?
0
0
By PikathePokePimp on 14 Apr 2020 13:35
If anyone want it too, message me.
EDIT : got it last nigt, thanks.
0
0
By Winters z99 on 19 Apr 2020 16:00
Jeffer steven65
0
0
By jeffer steven65 on 20 Apr 2020 04:23
Willing to boost this one, add me or message me.
0
0
By Danny374 on 20 Apr 2020 09:13
I could use some help with this one, and help out others. I’m just about 25, and I haven’t seen this come up once.
0
0
By KenKenWorldWide on 25 Apr 2020 23:19
Please help me. Message me or add me
0
0
By ThatGuyOzzy19 on 26 Apr 2020 07:56
I can help message me on xbox if you still need the Achievement. I can help maybe if few of you are all online at the same time we can arrange this.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 26 Apr 2020 11:03
Ciao I can help on this, if you need to complete. Send me a message in case. Ciao.
0
0
By daniele duns4 on 28 Apr 2020 08:31
Need help boosting this
0
0
By BearThrillss on 28 Apr 2020 14:32
Anyone please willing to help on this?
0
0
By Wolfville12 on 01 May 2020 06:02
I could also need some help boosting this, noticed that the previous posters already got it.
0
0
By Gammeltroll on 03 May 2020 12:38
Someone can help me to boost this achievement please ?

GT : Monsieur Maire
0
0
By Jay Kriiis on 05 May 2020 16:48
I am also desperately looking for someone to boost this, its my last one for this game!
0
0
By DJ Traxion on 06 May 2020 01:04
Looking to boost this one too. Shoot me a message!

GT: Tinzkiziwa
0
0
By TinzkiZiwa on 06 May 2020 23:07
Also looking to boost this GT: JonoDeGooseman
0
0
By JonoDeGooseman on 07 May 2020 09:49
Also looking to boost this GT: JonoDeGooseman
0
0
By JonoDeGooseman on 07 May 2020 11:02
Need help with this, my GT is IL Matii
0
0
By on 11 May 2020 22:07
Boost this on xbox Caleb9359 please
0
0
By Pseudonymous on 15 May 2020 06:06
Hit me up if anyone wants to try this out GT PointlessAgate5
0
0
By PointlessAgate5 on 18 May 2020 03:04
Looking to boost.
0
0
By JefeGator on 26 May 2020 04:22
Anyone willing to boost this add me Rob7Ellis and drop me a message. Thanks
0
0
By Rob7Ellis on 01 Jun 2020 09:04
anyone want to boost message me or join my session for tomorrow
0
0
By King KRool on 21 Jun 2020 22:47
whenever I do a mission with a cutscene it puts me into a different session as my boosting partner
0
0
By King KRool on 22 Jun 2020 00:07
Really? That's odd, hopefully it is just a temporary thing maybe try again again another day
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 22 Jun 2020 00:43
Looking for someone to boost this, send me a message on Xbox (GT = JuanmaEiroa)
0
0
By JuanmaEiroa on 04 Jul 2020 19:27
Need this and pretty much every RD Online achievement.

Gt: J The Altruist
0
0
By J ROLL 1998 on 24 Jul 2020 19:22
Not sure whats going on. Me and a boosting partner had zero luck. No prompts for countering our respective missions despite being in opposing posses. Heck, some strangers wont even allow us to accept a mission from them. Might be a new issue with the latest update.
Message me if you're up to attempt boosting
GT: J The Altruist
0
0
By J ROLL 1998 on 06 Aug 2020 04:10
I had this too recently whilst trying to help someone get the achievement but I think it has to do with how busy the server is with people and events and the time of day. I am happy to help you, shoot me a message when on Xbox and we can give it a go. Players are still unlocking the achievement no problem according to the Recent Winners list, so do not be too disheartened.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 06 Aug 2020 10:37
Need this one GT kenshin20
0
0
By kenshin20 on 16 Aug 2020 00:22
I have my own posse so if someone wants to do this with me before the game leaves game pass send me a message on xbox live.

GT: topux
0
0
By topux on 19 Aug 2020 10:53
Looking someone to boost this one
0
0
By AlvarezKing1 on 17 Sep 2020 01:51
Hi need help with this happy to boost and help with other achievements
0
0
By Mr Ashby on 17 Sep 2020 19:13
The Achievement is working again. Someone I played the game with this morning unlocked it.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 03 Oct 2020 10:36
I’m down to boost hazard
0
0
By DaGuitarHero1 on 13 Oct 2020 14:28
Boost?
0
0
By grittysquirrels on 30 Nov 2020 05:01
Anyone willing to help me get this achievement?

GT: aintmuch2say
0
0
By Tr45tytg on 18 Dec 2020 23:59
I`ll do the Achievement with you in the morning.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 19 Dec 2020 20:38
Was in a free roam session with a friend last night and when he went to start a stranger mission, he disappeared from my map and was put in his own session. Any way to prevent that from happening?
0
0
By SquiSquiSquidio on 25 Dec 2020 03:06
Anyone want to do this add me DeltaGolf96
0
0
By DeltaGolf96 on 17 Jan 2021 16:31
Need help doing this send me a message if you can
0
0
By CombatHat046 on 30 Jan 2021 11:16
I will shoot you a message on xbl when I am next online @CombatHat046 and we can get it done if you want probably on Sunday.
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 30 Jan 2021 21:56
Would like a partner for this as well. MSG me on live!
Got help thanks!
0
0
By Bear5 Fan 4Ever on 12 Feb 2021 10:17
OR7A need this and Strength in Numbers. Available anytime, DM me on XBLn
0
0
By OR7A on 16 Feb 2021 22:17
I need a partner for this one. Message me on live, and off course i return the favor
0
0
By Hyp3rNova NL on 04 Apr 2021 22:26
I need a partner for this one too. Gt : Efferalgan
0
0
By Efferalgan on 30 May 2021 12:03
Need a partner, GT: Mythunde
0
0
By Mythunde on 02 Jun 2021 15:35
** done
0
0
By Halder on 21 Jun 2021 13:54
Would love help with this one. Gt: GlowChicken
0
0
By GlowChicken on 23 Jul 2021 07:01
Anybody else having issues with this not unlocking? I've countered my friends mission plenty of times, done different missions and the Bonnie one mentioned above but no unlock? Was anyone facing this issue and able to overcome?
0
0
By TheLooseGoose18 on 14 Aug 2021 10:54
Can anybody help me with that?, GT: zseekonbush007
0
0
By ZseekOnBush007 on 29 Aug 2021 19:26
Anyone available to help me boost this, GT is PlatinumKing92
0
0
By PlatinumKing92 on 20 Oct 2021 00:35
I need this achievement desperately, please help im on xbox too
0
0
By Noremac#2586 on 18 Mar 2024 02:00
Looking for help yo Boost this achiev. GT: SecuSellan
0
0
By SecuSellan on 29 Dec 2021 11:13
Message GT: Saintjimmyyyy for help boosting this achiv!
0
0
By saintjimmyyyy on 23 Jan 2022 22:23
lf 3 players to boost for this achievement + The Real Deal. GT: Bedouin Chant.
0
0
By Jurhum on 21 Feb 2022 11:27
Need another player for achievement message GT:mememaster1217
0
0
By mememaster1217 on 28 Feb 2022 20:41
Anyone looking to team up on this? GT Sturge 14
0
0
By Sturge 14 on 31 Mar 2022 00:05
Anyone still needing to do it? add my GT
0
0
By Benodarks47 on 23 Apr 2022 20:23
I still need this add me if you do too
0
0
By Grusselgrosser on 05 May 2022 03:31
Can anyone help me do this if so add my gt
0
0
By xUND3RTAK3RxRKO on 07 May 2022 05:31
Add me if you need help with this - still need this as well
0
0
By MrOGamertag on 12 Jul 2022 22:24
Looking to boost this with the 2 player method in the guide.
0
0
By unnerving probe on 15 Aug 2022 21:22
Add me to get this done quickly
gt fpsgoku420
0
0
By FpsGoku420 on 01 Sep 2022 04:04
Add me: Mr Bonth to get this one done
0
0
By Mr Bonth on 05 Sep 2022 12:01
Need help please
0
0
By LewisWatsoon on 11 Nov 2022 07:08
Need help please
0
0
By LewisWatsoon on 11 Nov 2022 14:43
Can some one help please
0
0
By LewisWatsoon on 20 Nov 2022 11:41
Ossentowski I can help you with this on Sunday morning if you wish?
0
0
By Petrolium Bear on 17 Dec 2022 18:27
If anyone can help me with this, would be much appreciated

Update: Had a few responses and 4 of us now have this!!
0
0
By RAVEN E67 on 30 Dec 2022 19:22
Need help as well, would be great
0
0
By Alexinator07 on 17 Jan 2023 18:16
GT: spades59
0
0
By spades59 on 20 Jan 2023 19:38
Definitely need to boost this, hmu Gj80 👍🏻
0
0
By Gj80 on 20 Jan 2023 21:24
I need this achievement done hmu if interested
0
0
By Random gg#8551 on 02 Feb 2023 22:34
looking for a boost, lemme know if you're up for it. I'll help you out too
0
0
By FUS ROH DERP on 07 Feb 2023 00:33
looking for help, will also help if needed
0
0
By rvnkd on 07 Feb 2023 22:03
.
0
0
By KarlaSouzaRJ on 09 Feb 2023 19:34
Looking for help with this, and will help you too
0
0
By Lewitunes on 19 Feb 2023 18:45
Can somebody help with that one? I will help you back if you need it
0
0
By KaZzzidze on 26 Feb 2023 17:56
need help with this one, I can help too..
0
0
By EmreTR1094 on 28 Feb 2023 13:11
I need help, my gamertag is AxsusGt7
0
0
By AxsusGT7 on 05 Mar 2023 07:40
I’m looking to boost this as well. If no one responds in a couple days I’ll setup a session
0
0
By PHATFree86 on 11 Mar 2023 21:00
Also need help with this one.
0
0
By Dotty Rocks on 12 Mar 2023 16:25
I just created a boosting session if anyone wants to join
0
0
By PHATFree86 on 15 Mar 2023 03:03
Looking to get this done. Send us a message GT will i am not
0
0
By will i am not on 14 May 2023 18:46
If Someone wanna do this Hit me up
0
0
By DerXboxJoey3 on 15 Jun 2023 20:17
If someone wants to do MVP 3 wins achievement Add me. building a team of 4. Xbox

Buda94#8286
0
0
By Buda94 on 22 Jun 2023 11:46
Looking to do this, and all other multiplayer needed achievements, message me on Xbox to get this done- thebigballa23
0
0
By TheBigBalla23 on 01 Aug 2023 22:55
I need this achievement and Strength in Numbers. Send me a message either on here or on Xbox so we can set something up :)
0
0
By JWB XCIX on 06 Aug 2023 13:02
Anyone who wants this. Message me. Needing it too
0
0
By Call of Craig on 20 Aug 2023 17:08
Anyone wanna do this, I need it also
0
0
By sENDmeMEsNOW on 30 Aug 2023 11:14
I need it too.
0
0
By MikeSkullo on 08 Sep 2023 13:04
msg me if anyone wants to do this, i need it
0
0
By Benny B00 on 10 Sep 2023 04:28
Looking for someone to boost this with please
0
0
By dollsing on 20 Nov 2023 14:08
Need this achievement, can someone help? I’m happy to return the favor or help with whatever else you need
0
0
By DHU RoLLTide on 08 Feb 2024 03:31
i can help DHU RollTide add me
0
0
By Kunvay on 12 Feb 2024 04:05
I need this one too, can someone help out?
0
0
By NMount on 12 Feb 2024 19:19
I need this! GT is JPG x. Message/add me if you can help and I'll return the favour if needed!
0
0
By JPG x on 14 Feb 2024 06:05
Need this to GT is I Dulac I message me or add i can help in return no stress
0
0
By I Dulac I on 20 Feb 2024 10:57
Need this achievement willing to help anyone who does too
0
0
By TickUs on 10 Mar 2024 21:46
can you help me too? (I play RDR2 on PC)
0
0
By Enderforl on 11 Apr 2024 10:59
I need this achivement. My gt is CroakyCascade67. You scratch my back I scratch yours.
0
0
By CroakyCascade67 on 14 Apr 2024 16:37
I need this too, I am playing on pc my rockstar gt is xHasco, xbox gt is Hasco#9236
0
0
By Hasco on 24 Apr 2024 18:09
need help with this. gamertag is NDX
0
0
By ndx on 27 Apr 2024 13:44
Looking for help as well for this. Gt is BarredQuasar134
0
0
By BarredQuasar134 on 31 May 2024 03:47
Just going to add that you can do this solo. If you find a posse moving a couple of wagons, destroy even one of them, the achievement will pop. I got this after being spawned in free roam and got to these guys and blew up one wagon while the other was delivered. Totally luck-based. But if you’re just playing online in solo it can happen organically.
0
0
By CracklyKlover on 15 Oct 2019 22:36
Looking to boost this GT: Panda Xpress XP
0
0
By Panda Xpress XP on 08 May 2020 16:26
Not sure whats going on. Me and a boosting partner had zero luck. No prompts for countering our respective missions despite being in opposing posses. Heck, some strangers wont even allow us to accept a mission from them. Might be a new issue with the latest update.
Message me if you're up to attempt boosting
GT: J The Altruist
0
0
By J ROLL 1998 on 04 Aug 2020 04:55
I need help with this achievement. If anyone is available, here is my Gamertag : RSC Jay
I can help too ;-)
0
0
By RSC Jay on 21 Nov 2021 17:15
I would like to unlock this achievement. Send a message to Gods Are Silent if you would are interested in unlocking it too!
0
0
By Gods Are Silent on 01 Dec 2021 02:32
lf 3 players to boost for this achievement + The Real Deal. GT: Bedouin Chant.
0
0
By Jurhum on 21 Feb 2022 16:03
need this too. happy to assist, Daddy Fridges is gt
0
0
By Daddy Fridges on 07 Apr 2024 14:22
View all 172 comments Show less comments
For anyone who plays solo or does not feel like boosting, I have some tips! Though it will still involve a bit of luck.

-Make sure you have Dynamite or Fire Bottles in your inventory!

-I played a lot in Free Roam around Scarlet Meadows (the area around Rhodes). Note that there is a Free Roam mission the requires the player to bring 1 or 2 wagons to the mansion at Braithwaite Manor. The luck involves another player doing this mission while you are in the area!

-If you see a blue dot (another online player) traveling on a wagon (with possibly another behind them) on a road leading to Braithwaite Manor then odds are they are doing this mission.

-Follow behind them until they reach the long straight road south to the mansion. When they reach that road it should say "Attack another Player's Free Roam Mission"

-At this point, don't bother shooting the player or horses. Just equip your dynamite or fire bottles and toss 2-3 at one of the wagons. As long as you destroy at least one of the wagons the achievement should unlock (even if the player delivers the other one)!

The dynamite method should work for any delivery mission but I found that the delivery mission by Braithwaite Manor seemed to be most striaghtforward (literally) for others still struggling with this achievement.

There is some good hunting (boars, deer, coyotes) and easy access to shops in Rhodes if you set up camp in Scarlet Meadows and are waiting around trying your luck out at this. Best of luck!
13
2

17 Nov 2019 23:48

2 Comments
Please Me Help Red Dead Redemption 2 Achievement cry
0
0
By TheRetroVHS on 20 Nov 2019 04:08
My tag is “WoozyIvy1049462”
0
0
By WoozyIvy1049462 on 05 Aug 2020 22:27
To earn the All's Fair trophy in Red Dead Online, you simply need to thwart another player or team's attempt to complete a Free Roam mission -- i.e. a non-story mission that takes place in the shared world with all players.

The easiest mission to counter is a stagecoach robbery, which will appear as a red reticle on a black circle background on the mini-map. Head over and deal with whoever is in the area, which may still be the original NPCs or may be a group of players (hopefully you catch them off guard in these early days, and it's just the one guy).

In the early game you may not have anything to destroy the coach with efficiently such as dynamite. Your best bet is to kill or free the horses, drive the whole thing off a cliff or, my method, drive it into the deep part of a river, lake or the sea. The horses will be freed and the stagecoach technically destroyed.
5
0

03 Dec 2018 12:40

8 Comments
Anyone willing to help? If yes, PM me, my PSN: GampxS
0
0
By GampxS on 02 Aug 2019 10:45
I just learned a key bit of information for this one. If you are playing in Defensive mode, you will not be offered the option to counter a rival posse. It tells you to come out of Defensive mode to get the counter option, but you then have to wait 30 seconds for that to happen which could make it too late.

So when looking for this, always use Offensive mode
0
0
By BeardedScot86 on 05 Mar 2020 10:32
I've made a boost session for this weekend, if anyone wants to come just pst me on PSN.
0
0
By Jmech1986 on 04 Jun 2020 15:45
I only need this and 'Strength in Numbers' for the plat if anyone is willing to help me out.

PSN: Metabolic-V
0
0
By Metabolic-V on 28 Sep 2020 21:24
Hey, need help on this one. I have a mic to communicate easier. If anyone wants to boost for it, send me a message.

PSN: HockeyFan7920
0
0
By HockeyFan7920 on 07 Sep 2021 17:28
Looking for a partner to boost this one. Send me a message.

PSN: Witcher7410
0
0
By Witcher7410 on 18 Dec 2022 14:49
Looking for someone to help get this trophy.

PSN: ItsAllGdMn89_

Message me
0
0
By ItsAllGdMn89_ on 20 Nov 2023 15:16
A humble addition : it seems that successfully surviving when being targetted for assassination counts as well.
Some stranger free roam missions ask to kill a random NPC or player. If you are chosen as a target, you can counter the mission of your opponent by surviving.
I would suggest to go for a decent horse (mine is criollo) anse keep a couple of stimulant and wild carrots just in case. And run.

You can also boost with a single other player. Both need to have permanent posse. Then, accept a mission (Mac Farlane ranch for example) of kidnapping or coach stealing. The one you boost with will have a notification. He needs to prevent the mission. Swap, rince and repeat, trophy unlocked for both.

I can help you, add me : Khassandr125
0
0
By Khassandr125 on 28 Apr 2020 12:32
View all 8 comments Show less comments
This one can easily be boosted with two players.

Start an online free roam session then invite a friend or have him/her join your session. Have each person create their own posse (set it to private). Ride to a mission that is far away from all the other players in the server so that they won't interfere. The person that is not going for the trophy starts the mission (delivery missions are the easiest to do). As soon as the message "Rival players can now counter your mission" appears tell that to your partner so that he/she can counter your mission. When the mission fails the other person should get the trophy.

Another easy method is to utilise the free Roam missions where the objective is to assassinate a player. If you are ever the target of one of this missions leave what you are doing, open your map and see where the rival player is coming from (red player on the map), put a waypoint on the opposite side the rival is coming from and start riding your horse until the timer expires, it will cause the other player's mission to fail and give you the trophy.

[Credit to Jvaferreria]
0
0
Just show up for another gang's mission and shoot everyone. There must be a squad of enemies. The easiest way is to come to clear the lair.
7
0

27 Nov 2018 19:34

12 Comments
It is easiest to perform when the enemy unit is carrying a stagecoach. Take dynamite (often found when searching corpses) and throw it under the wheels. I completed this trophy purely by accident.
4
0
By BryukBond on 12 Dec 2018 14:27
After the summer 2020 patch, players began to take on missions from strangers much less often, and it became much more difficult to intercept the mission of someone else’s squad. I knocked it out like this: I found a dude on Facebook, agreed with him for a while, went into his session, we both went into our own squad (for this trophy you both need to be members of warring permanent squads), I shot him for enmity, he was reborn and took on a mission (to steal a horse and drive it to Saint-Denis), I shot him again)), got on the stolen horse and drove it to the indicated place. The trophy is mine. I can't imagine how you can get it yourself.
4
0
By toha_toha on 31 Jan 2021 15:24
It was possible to complete it only with a friend, he took the mission, invited him to his session (Steal a Stagecoach), came to the place, took the loot from him and brought it to the place. Find your friends and the trophy is yours!
2
0
By romansway777 on 09 Nov 2019 23:41
I followed all the advice - the task is not displayed, alas. I tried it at different times and in different areas. Need a partner. Click “need a partner” or write to a friend. They did it in 15 minutes for both me and him. Otherwise, the task simply does not pop up. We go to the station to the postman and take on the mission “escort the stagecoach.” Next, we take the fords into our own hands and slow it down; we do the same with the second cart (we run across to it). Be sure to kill one of you and accept enmity (square) before accepting the task. If the level is below 18 (no dynamite), you shoot at the wheels (spokes) of the cart, they fly apart (you need to shoot all the spokes on two wheels) and so on with two carts. It's easier with dynamite.
1
0
By airsteward on 08 May 2024 20:55
Boosts calmly with partners. Meet immediately at the mission site. One takes on a mission. Others in the squad take him down. The trophy is yours.
9
0
By NesvetskyLev on 07 Dec 2018 01:31
A squad is not necessarily needed, it works with one player too
6
0
By desdomain on 27 Jan 2019 18:36
We go to the squads section in the network menu, it should throw it into a random squad, if not, then restart it. It happened to me, I was thrown into a gang where this gang had already attacked two stagecoaches of another gang, we caught up with them and shot them, then we threw dynamite under the stagecoaches, the trophy was received, in fact it took 5 minutes.
0
0
By Marat655 on 16 Jan 2022 20:00
The trophy is a little problematic, because few people complete the tasks of strangers. Personally, I was looking online for someone who could help. We found a person, wrote, if he agreed, do the following:
1) The unit must be hostile (marked in red). To do this, simply ask to kill yourself.
2) The one who agreed to help you launches the stranger’s mission (preferably, it is the delivery of carts).
3) Then you simply hang around this player until you receive a notification that you can interfere with the hostile squad.
Then it's a matter of small things. Follow the mission. It all depends on what kind of mission was launched. The mission with the wagon is best suited, since you will just need to destroy it (or kill the horses of this wagon (by the way, it seems like they will not die if the player is sitting in the wagon, keep in mind))
0
0
By Mis_Fix on 18 Mar 2022 19:29
During the game, I often found myself in some kind of individual hub after the next cut-scene. In general, there is not a single player on the map. Because of this, while I was going through story missions and just wandering around the world, I didn’t come across a single message. The banal joining of an open squad with other players helped (you can create your own and invite anyone). Joined; minded his own business; I was no longer thrown into any individual hubs; the message popped up almost immediately; calmly made the trophy (throw dynamite at everything and everyone).
1
0
By Tutik on 14 Dec 2018 15:37
Now it is impossible to complete this trophy alone, because more interesting and profitable sources of both experience and money with gold have appeared. I knocked it out thanks to one foreigner, I went into each session and wrote to several people, if they didn’t answer, I looked for the next one and repeated until they answered. I didn’t have to search for long and knocked out this trophy in 5 minutes. You and another player must be the main ones in different squads, the other player starts the task at the postman and then you wait until he writes to you that you can interfere with this player. In my case, I needed to blow up the player’s stagecoach, blew it up and after 5-10 seconds they gave me a trophy.
0
0
By ReactSSR on 02 Sep 2023 12:53
Everything is quite simple, at the moment there are many players in the game in the role of moonshiners and traders who often complete tasks on carts and knock out a trophy for them. You don’t have to be in a squad yourself, the most important thing is to turn on the “Aggressive” mode in the network game settings, then if one of the players performs similar missions near you, you will automatically be tasked with stopping your competitors, then it’s a matter of catching up with technology, throwing dynamite and you’re done.
It’s better to win a trophy in the evening; online there’s a better chance. In the Rhodes area, the chance of such a mission appearing is quite high, I advise you to just drive around the area in the evening in the area marked below and everything will work out, good luck!
0
0
By Apollo_026 on 19 Oct 2023 23:10
I did this with a friend. We took on the task in free mode, after the start, if you make an achievement for yourself, your friend must kill you and go on the task. Follow him, and no matter how much time has passed since the murder, even if your friend turns blue on the mini-map, you need to wait until the game informs you that you can interfere with the player. Then your friend will be highlighted with a red star in a black circle, and you, ATTENTION, need to complete the task for him. But! If this is a task of delivering people to a point, then you will need to kill them. It’s important that both of you must be in the squad, even if only one at a time. I tried to kill the person who needed to be delivered to the cannibals, and to blow up the cart, to no avail. And don’t take quests in cities, for example in Valentine, there you go literally around the corner, there wasn’t even a message that other players could place on you.
1
0
By npi_3pak on 25 Aug 2022 16:29
View all 12 comments Show less comments
Got a trophy when I was targeted by another player. I just ran from him and killed him. Survived 10 minutes and received the trophy.
3
0

10 Dec 2018 23:15