Red Dead Redemption

Red Dead Redemption

95 Achievements

1,500

85-111h

Xbox 360
Xbox One
Xbox Series
Log in or Register to track Red Dead Redemption achievements progress.
Dastardly

Dastardly

Place a hogtied woman on the train tracks, and witness her death by train.

5

How to unlock the Dastardly achievement in Red Dead Redemption - Definitive Guide

This achievement is called Dastardly
It requires you to place a hogtied woman on the train tracks, and witness her death by train

You will not be able to get this achievement until you obtain the lasso from Bonnie, I believe it's her fifth mission. Once you have it find a woman to lasso then hogtie her when she is down, I would recommend choosing a woman in the middle of nowhere so the town folk don't try to kill you. After that put her on your horse and see where the train is and the direction it's heading. Get on your horse and race to get far enough ahead of the train so that you have time to lay her down across the tracks, then watch her die for an easy 5G!
116
2

18 May 2010 22:48

40 Comments
lol
0
0
By Virtual James 7 on 19 May 2010 11:26
How in the heck does a person just randomly figure this achievement out?! I agree, LOL!
0
0
By Count Flanders on 19 May 2010 14:35
fuckin' lol'd
0
0
By TouchMyMinki on 19 May 2010 18:06
Oh come on! like most of you weren't going to do this in the game anyway. *twists villian moustache*

Muah ha ha ha

The hard part is waiting out the train. I waited like 10 mins last night for a train to come by but to no avail. Got fed up, watched house and went to bed lol
0
0
By StartSmallss on 19 May 2010 18:13
I didn't randomly figure it out, the achievements for this game has been listed on x360a.org for about a month, though I probably would have done it anyway like MAJOR SMALLMAN said.

I also agree that waiting for the train is the hardest part. Not sure how the train can turn around at the station and go the opposite way but it sometimes does.
0
0
By BlindAssassin24 on 20 May 2010 00:26
Taking the main trail from Bonnie's place to Thieves' Landing I had a woman run up asking for a ride and she stole my horse. I whistled and my horse bucked her, and I lassoed her and took her to the rails for the achievement. Not sure if this is totally random of if it's common in that area.
0
0
By Codsternation on 20 May 2010 05:35
had to do two attempts, first time I was sitting on my horse watching, and it didn't pop. Second time I stood by the tracks and it did.
0
0
By splicegraph on 20 May 2010 06:33
Yes, this is definitely the achievement of the year. It was freaking hilarious!
0
0
By AvengedAgainst on 20 May 2010 07:30
I did it without that lasso ability. When you save the random lady from being kidnapped (hanging around just about any town for more then 5 minutes will get this to pop), just leave her tied up, race to a train by horseback and drop her down. Got this one without even knowing...
0
0
By I am the batdan on 20 May 2010 16:10
...wait a minute dan, you randomly dropped off an already tied up woman on the train tracks after "rescuing" her and watched her die?

This achievement, and this solution, have made me want this game. Kudos Blindassassin.
0
0
By Dog of Thunder on 20 May 2010 16:21
I did the same as batdan. I heard a woman screaming and followed the blip to a villian carrying a hogtied woman. I just shot him, picked her up, and raced to the train.
0
0
By bogeygolf316 on 20 May 2010 18:01
Do you loose honor or can you use the bandanna so it doesn't move?
0
0
By PiMDx on 20 May 2010 20:06
best achievement i have done in a loooonnnnggg time, w00t w00t
0
0
By SHAD RADICAL on 23 May 2010 21:33
I found one of the easiest victims for this achievement was Jenny. This is the girl chatting up the priest at the start of the game, which you later encounter again for a stranger's mission. After the mission is completed, you and her will be all alone in the wild. You can capture her and take her to the train. Easy enough.
0
0
By RianFL on 29 May 2010 10:41
Picking the kidnapper's victim has the advantage of not losing honor/alerting lawmen/etc ;)
And beware of Mission Triggers! I screwed my first try by acidentally riding over one.
0
0
By on 31 May 2010 13:07
Those concerned about such outdated concepts as "honor" could, of course, just reload from their previous save after the achievement has been unlocked. But it's not as if there's plenty of opportunity to regain your lost honor.
0
0
By Kelvin Thorn on 15 Jun 2010 18:28
I had to do it twice, it apparently doesn't work with soiled doves.
0
0
By CAP n C0RNBREAD on 30 Jun 2010 00:08
Picked up a chick in Blackwater. Train was coming right through town. Easy, and one of the most fun chieve's yet =)
0
0
By Ginuwine AI3 on 16 Aug 2010 05:04
You guys are some sick bastards. :P
0
0
By CM Trance on 24 Aug 2010 04:50
I would like to add, BlindAssassin24, that in order to not wait so long for the train, check your map in the start menu. If you notice, the red train icon changes place every time. That is because the red train icon IS the train, so when you get the hogtied woman, look for that icon and follow it, because there's only one train in the game constantly moving around the map. Otherwise, nice guide.
0
0
By Redodua on 27 Dec 2010 19:22
OK, so i dropped 2 hog-tied women on to the tracks and had them killed by the blue train - no achievement.

I dropped 1 under the red train and it popped. Anyone else encounter this?
0
0
By Skinstakovic on 01 Feb 2011 13:09
It took me 3 tries to get the cheevo pop. Basically you probably mustn't be on your horse nor place the hogtied woman on the tracks more than 1mn before the train arrives.
0
0
By SuupaaTenkei on 13 Mar 2011 23:15
I had zero luck with blue train on several attempts, as soon as I tried with the red and it popped
0
0
By Baussie on 03 Apr 2011 12:18
Tried it last night with the Blue train and no luck.
0
0
By Toby1Kenob1 on 13 Apr 2011 08:45
Also no luck with the red train...
0
0
By Toby1Kenob1 on 17 Apr 2011 10:25
Same with me, it did not unlock the first time i tried. Guess i wasnt looking right at her. Had to do it again. Make sure you have her and the train in clear visibility.
0
0
By VEGA006XX on 12 Feb 2012 16:44
LOL...some of these random achievements are just too funny.
0
0
By Solario32 on 09 Mar 2013 15:14
Can you still get this on undead nightmare dlc?
0
0
By sK1tZO420 on 01 Jan 2014 15:41
Can you still get this on undead nightmare dlc?
0
0
By sK1tZO420 on 01 Jan 2014 16:03
I did ths randomly with a man. It stoped the train and glitched I could not get him off or move the train.
0
0
By NIXXION44 on 08 Feb 2014 22:14
Being on horseback made no difference for me, but I did directly watch her die. It's been a long time since these comments so maybe it's been fixed since?
0
0
By OccipitalFox on 02 Jul 2016 12:40
Just read the description for this.

XD

Oh, if this game was released today...
0
0
By Maiden Ty One on 04 Nov 2018 18:25
I just tried it twice and both times the woman actually stopped the train!

The train just stops and judders until you remove her from the track, at which point it teleports you to the inside of the train.

Glitchy, glitchy.
0
0
By Maiden Ty One on 04 Nov 2018 19:04
@Phoenix C64 - I'm Irish and I thought the character 'Irish' was hilarious :). Most Irish people find Irish stereotypes hilarious. With these things it's nearly always a loud minority-within-the-minority who gets a stick up their ass about it.
0
0
By Maiden Ty One on 04 Nov 2018 19:07
So this one didn’t pop for me either in 4 tries. Then I changed my outfit to the standard outfit (I was wearing the gentleman’s suite before) and first try - achievement unlocked. Can’t say for sure it’s the outfit but worth a try ;)
0
0
By ProjectOasis on 06 Feb 2020 18:45
Can confirm - changing back to the standard outfit seems to help this unlock
0
0
By Mada on 01 Jan 2023 13:09
.
0
0
By KarlaSouzaRJ on 09 Feb 2023 19:51
Basically hog tie an innocent women then drag them onto a train track and watch as they get ran over by the train and then it should pop
0
0
By WyattT2009 on 27 Mar 2024 13:53
You cannot be on horseback and must stare directly at the woman getting run over.

I was on horseback and watched the engine go past on the first attempt and got nothing, then ran ahead of it and tossed a girl from the MacFarlane Ranch on the tracks ahead of the station there, stared directly at her on foot, and got the achievement.
0
0
By Mobius Evalon on 30 Jan 2012 04:28
every1 better get this achievement quick, before rockstar removes it. irish people already whining about the irish NPC in game... so some1 will notice and start whining about this sooner or later.

anyways, back to topic: a good moment to do this is when you're doing "Friends in High Places" chievo. the one with the 5000$ bounty on your head. as you won't care any1 seeing you hogtie a woman anyways.
0
0
By Phoenix C64 on 27 May 2010 07:21
View all 40 comments Show less comments
For those who struggle with this achievement.
I might have been unlucky but I had tried for this achievement several times and it did not pop. Once when I laid the woman on the track I realized that Marston actually looked aside. A way to control where you look is aiming with your pistol, so next time I tried it that way. I laid a whore on the tracks, aimed at her with my pistol, watched her blowing into pieces when the train ran her over - may her rest in piece - and got the achievement.
29
0

26 Jul 2011 18:32

3 Comments
Thanks Mate I'd killed three of them with no cheevo tried your guide and it popped first time on the fourth..sweet thanx
0
0
By rockinroosters on 27 Nov 2011 21:12
IMHO, best guide for this achievement
0
0
By x SATELE SHAN x on 19 Mar 2019 22:25
I was able to wear the bandana in the cowboy clothes and got it to pop with your solution. Didn’t read anywhere about the bandana negating it but did see some mentions certain clothes negated it.
0
0
By Fable72 on 19 Dec 2023 23:48
View all 3 comments Show less comments
I happened to have gotten this achievement very fast and by coincidence while i tried to do it as GrandmasterALK suggested. I was on my way to Nosalida when all of a sudden a woman with a bunch of dudes cried for help. Remember the situation, woman screams, blue dot pops up in mini map and when you get closer the guys start shooting at you, does that ring a bell? So i went dead eye, shot all the guys and then i realized on the mini map that the blue dot changed into a red one. I changed to lasso, hogtied the woman who started that mess, took her to the train track, train was passing (coincidently) and cheevo popped. This took around 1:30 minutes real time.
26
1

08 Jun 2010 18:39

1 Comment
Just to add my twocents on the location...I did it the way Onkel B mentioned just outside Chuparosa. Exit Chuparosa on the westside (left) and go take a left. You're now on the road south of Chuparosa. On the map where the "H" stands I found the woman with the dudes.
0
0
By TomaShevskyNL on 29 Nov 2010 15:52
Not really another method but thought I would add that an easy place to achieve this is when you bring medicine for a female stranger standing in the middle of nowhere. I think her name is Jenny. But be careful because when you pull out your lasso she runs away. But after you have caught her this achievement is pretty simple as all you do then is hogtie her before you put her on a horse and take her to train track and wait there until the train runs her over then -click- achievement unlocked. Definately one of the most fun achievements I have ever done.
25
8

21 May 2010 20:53

This is the Tutorial I did on how to get the Secret Dastardly achievement which is to Hogtie a women place on the train tracks and watch as the train runs her over...
24
4

03 Jun 2010 11:20

Credit for the video goes to Achievement Hunters/RoosterTeeth. Find a women (preferably away from others so they dont shoot you) and take out your lasso and hogtie her. Now find out where the train is and dump her down on the tracks alittle in front of the train so you dont get run over in the process. After she dies the achievement should pop up.
19
0

31 Aug 2010 17:15

Okay, so just started the game, was riding around, just south of gaptooth ridge. A little more south than cueva seca. Came across a guy at a camp, with a woman already hog tied. Killed him, picked up girl, walked down to the train line, placed her on the tracks, mounted my pony, walked forward a little, turned around and watched. Train came past with in a few minutes.... POP...
8
1

17 Jun 2013 17:27

I choose to get a woman from Armadillo to hogtie. On the third or fourth attempt I made it out of the town without dying.
5
1

20 Jul 2019 07:02

Get a woman, you can find them anywhere but if you're having a hard time finding one then go to the nearest town e.g. Armadillo. Equip your Lasso by bringing up the weapon wheel (hold ) and aim it by locking onto a woman in the street with , get close to the lady then release the Lasso with and hogtie her with . Place her on your horse and ride to McFarlane's Ranch, there will be a train station there. Wait for the train to arrive and stop, place the woman on the train tracks and move out of the way and enjoy the show. Just make sure the camera angle is looking at the woman or her death won't count.

If this trophy does not unlock then attempt it again by using the opposite train as there are two different colored trains i.e one blue and one red. If the trophy did not unlock by using the red train to run over the victim, try using the opposite train i.e blue.

For more information on this possible glitch, please refer to this link: Dastardly Trophy Glitch.

0
0

Before you can attempt this achievement you will need to lasso, which you earn from Bonnie in the early missions. Once you do have it you can lasso and hogtie any women you desire, though there are some, which are easier than others. If you don't want to damage your fame or honor you can buy a bandana from Thieves' Land at the tailors shop.

Once you have either item you can now lasso your victim. Lasso and hogtie the lady of choice and place her on your horse. You can now make your way to the train track, check your map to see where the active train is. You will be looking for red train icon following the tracks. Head towards the train and play your victim on the tracks by pressing . Now just stand back and watch as the train plows down your victim and the achievement unlocks.

0
0
I took a woman who, along with bandits by the road, asks for help, stopping near them, they attack, so I don’t feel sorry for her, I shot the bandits, and tied her up with a lasso and put her on the nearest railway tracks.
Using the map you can track where the trains are.
All that remains is to wait and watch.
2
0

14 Jan 2024 19:05