Remothered: Broken Porcelain

I took Ashmann down in chapter 2 with throwables, took down Elisa with knives, and took down the nun, kept getting her to listen to the jukebox (stayed up the stairs to the right of the jukebox and stayed behind the railing then walked down the stairs the moment she got there and stabbed her with like 2 corrosive weapons and 2-4 normal weapons and that made her go down. I came on here to ask about porcelain but now I know I just have to beat him in story mission, which is fantastic.

Normally it should pop with story.If not, you can bring him down in the last room of the game

Nope, later again, you'll fight him with a real weapon ;-)

Crap... I beat the game I guess I didn't down that guy, can you tell me exactly when it is so that I don't miss him in my second playthrough?

I can confirm I had to knock out every enemy including the nun and porcelain to unlock this - defeating porcelain as per the story does NOT count. I hit him with an upgraded brick in the projector room then stabbed him in the back, that was all it took. Weirdly when he got knocked out, he was still stood bolt upright but wouldnt move haha

Same thing for me as Funky Monkee for Porcelain

This is not unlocking for me, no matter what I do. I brought down everyone on multiple saves, and even every single dumbass on the same save.
Awful game, by the way. Awful game.

Yes this seems buggy. I've knocked out every Stalker multiple Times (in one run, across 3 runs) and nothing popped for me.

Seems broke...sigh. Knocked down Amanda, Elisa, Ashland, and the Red Nun until they were completely lying down and they took about 8 seconds to get back up. Hit and stabed Porcelain in the cinema room until he went up into to air ducts many times. What am I doing wrong?

Like CyberneticHFX it seems like i can’t knock out Porcelain. This is my last achievement i need, i knocked out everyone else multiple times without problems but then i tried to knock out Porcelain at the end of the game throwing at him everything especially crafted things then stabbing him multiple times but at some point he ran away using like the holes in ceiling of the room and come back after some , repeated this process for ages and he can’t go down. What am I doing wrong?

Guys, this game is kinda broken, as the title suggests. I wrote on Mindstorm facebook page a couple of weeks ago telling them this achievement was not unlocking, and they said they'd forward my message to the developers. Let's see if they release an update.

Thank you for your comments. I decided to wait for a software update then. Also the Moth Ability became unavailable after loading from a Checkpoint overriden (any status loaded from a Save at that point, may just be that way) manual Save status, which makes this even more uncomfortable. I even suggest to store a manual Save status before going down to the basement at all, due to that fact. Though, attempts from farther back are even more tedious that way. It can have to do something with that. I tried again and again even though I stated I would not. Not a chance. Is that even still possible to achieve? Or is Porcelain not even in the relative hit list? More information is needed. Please!

I see on their patch notes on twitter they released an update for PS4 to fix the trophy. Hopefully a patch for the Xbox One version drops soon.

New update dropped. I can confirm it fixed the achievement. I had a save right by the final Porcelain fight in the basement. Got the film reel in the cinema room. Went back down and threw a bunch of stuff at him and the achievement popped.

Yep. Finally fixed.

For me it unlocked after knock down Andrea, Ashman, Elisa in chapter 3.

"Update" (Note - You don't need to worry about Andrea since you have to down her at chapter 1. The ones that you need to stab until there down is Ashman & Elisa Since this is miss-able, do this at the Kitchen, will be hard but it will get you one step closer to getting the achievement, If you're having trouble just go after Elisa. Later on after you get the tape for the cinema room just stab Ashman until he is down before you move on to the next section.)

The Red Nun & Porcelain seems to not go down after you stab them multiple times.

So you don't need to stab them since you down both later in the story. But just in case just stab them once and then continue on with the story.

(Stabbing these stalkers will also count towards the "Blood Bath Achievement" on whatever playthrough you are doing this on. )

Achievement should unlock after you defeat Porcelain in the garage or when you stab & defeat Ashman after acquiring the cinema tape.

Hope this helps you to get the achievement!

I am unable to knock out Porcelain, and I can not tell why either. I used every (+Crafted) throw-able Item available on it, and tried to use Defense Items, but they cease to function for being used as Sneak Attack Items with an unknown reason. That is why I barely put Defense Items to (the required) use. Is that based on an error? Or am I really lacking skill/knowledge? But I guess it is really just Broken Porcelain. Of course, I have all Moth Abilities fully developed, and tried this on different systems and save states for a cumulative time of likely 5h or so. I put the present information to use with no avail. Any additional information is most appreciated.