Return to Monkey Island

This achievement can be unlocked during "Part IV - Things Get Complicated", while you are playing as Guybrush. Progress through the story until meeting Widey Bones and exhausting the dialogue with her outside the International House of Mojo. To set sail, you will also need to get a sea map of the islands, which you can get from Wally's Maps-n-More. From now on, you are free to explore the whole of Melee Island once again and to navigate the sea.

Go to the Fish shop on High Street. Depending on which difficulty you're playing on, you will need to do two separate actions:
Casual Mode - interact twice with the Goldfish in the fishbowl next to the door
Hard Mode - interact twice with Bella Fisher's flag, that's hanging from the ceiling

After finding out about the secret club, ask to join them, and you will receive a fishing lure. With this lure, you need to find 5 secret members of the chums and show it to them so that you can receive advice regarding a better storytelling technique. It doesn't matter how you build your story at this point as long as you talk and receive advice from all 5 members.

The 5 Members

1. Locke Smith - Found on high street in her shop.
2. Pirate lady - in the Docks area, in front of the now-destroyed Scumm Bar.
3. Elaine - on Scurvy Island.
4. Apple Bob - on LeChuck's ship, on the upper deck hanging upside down.
5. Prison Guard - on Brr Muda, guarding the entrance to the Ice Quarry

After learning the secrets of the Angler storytelling, head back to Melee Island, to the Fish Shop, and show the lure to any of the three old pirate leaders. Then, make the following choices to tell the most whopper of a story:

1. I had broken through a blockade as thick and deadly as the crab bisque at the Scumm Bar.

2. My ship was swallowed by a huge lunker of a whale, a real chum-chomping line-breaker if ever there was one.

3. Inside it was like walking on soft cheese, with rivers of pea soup that stank like a landlubber's baitbox.

4. I made a fishing line with my own hair.

5. The creature lit out like an old tar from a bar of soap. Of course, then we had to put out the fire.

This achievement is missable (if you don't play the game on Hard Mode) and can only be done in Part 4. In order to unlock this achievement, you need to become a Prize Chum. To become a Prize Chum, you need first to ask the shopkeepers about the flag hanging above the door in the fish shop. Then, you need to improve your storytelling skill by showing up your fishing lure to these people:

- The pirate outside the Scumm bar
- Locke Smith in her shop
- Elaine in the lime grove on Scurvy Island
- Apple Bob on LeChuck's ship
- The ice quarry guard on Brrr Muda

When you are done, go back to the fish shop, show you fishing lure to the storekeepers and tell your story to become a Prize Chum !

Trophy Fisher Achievement: