Rise of the Argonauts

During the game you will enter into conversations that require you to give a response. Of these you need to make 5 of the same colour to obtain the achievement, so for Ares you need to pick the red coloured answers. When you go to select your answer, it will show the colour it is aligned with.

Note that not always will all 4 options be available.

whenever a dialogue box comes up and you have to choose a reply. there are icons in the centre circle. each representing one of the gods. simply choose 5 ares aligned choices