Sandlot Sluggers

1. Start a game with two controllers. Play as home.
2. Have the 2nd controller bunt, and let them reach 2nd base.
3. Either strike out the next three batters or have them bunt and throw them out.
4. The achievement will pop at the end of the inning.

I would recommend playing a pick-up game against a second controller. Let the second controller get a hit or bunt with their first batter and allow them to run around the bases to 2nd or 3rd instead of throwing them out. After their first batter is aboard, simply go the rest of the game throwing strikeouts and not scoring any runs with the second controller and you'll get this.