Sherlock Holmes Chapter One
39 Achievements
20-25h
PS5
Guilty!
Present accurate evidence in all accusations.
10.5%
How to unlock the Guilty! achievement in Sherlock Holmes Chapter One - Definitive Guide
NoHeroes94
TrueAchievements
TrueAchievements
Accusations are case ending mechanics exclusive to some of the side cases in this game, replacing the mind palace from the main story cases.
There are only three side cases which have this accusation mechanic. For this achievement, you need to complete all three cases accusing the correct person, with the correct evidence, in the correct order. If you provide the correct evidence, but in the wrong order, this will void the achievement.
I will include the cases, and then correct suspect/accusation/evidence order below. To accuse the below suspects, you need to have collected all key evidence, and have exhausted the majority to all of dialogue with all suspects/key individuals. If you can't accuse, you need to investigate/talk more!
Case 1: Love, Death, and Cordona (accepted from Mycroft's agent after completing "The Muse from Abroad, he's at the manor waiting for you).
Case 2: Blindsided (accepted by eavesdropping on two men inside the Cordona Newspaper Building. You need to have completed 'The Muse From Abroad' main story case, or you won't be able to eavesdrop on these individuals and accept the side-case.).
Case 3: Iron Coffin (accepted by eavesdropping on two women inside the Police Station. You need to have completed 'The Muse From Abroad' main story case, or you won't be able to eavesdrop on these individuals and accept the side-case.).
There are only three side cases which have this accusation mechanic. For this achievement, you need to complete all three cases accusing the correct person, with the correct evidence, in the correct order. If you provide the correct evidence, but in the wrong order, this will void the achievement.
I will include the cases, and then correct suspect/accusation/evidence order below. To accuse the below suspects, you need to have collected all key evidence, and have exhausted the majority to all of dialogue with all suspects/key individuals. If you can't accuse, you need to investigate/talk more!
Case 1: Love, Death, and Cordona (accepted from Mycroft's agent after completing "The Muse from Abroad, he's at the manor waiting for you).
Case 2: Blindsided (accepted by eavesdropping on two men inside the Cordona Newspaper Building. You need to have completed 'The Muse From Abroad' main story case, or you won't be able to eavesdrop on these individuals and accept the side-case.).
Case 3: Iron Coffin (accepted by eavesdropping on two women inside the Police Station. You need to have completed 'The Muse From Abroad' main story case, or you won't be able to eavesdrop on these individuals and accept the side-case.).
