Super Mega Baseball 2

Super Mega Baseball 2

42 Achievements

1,000

25-30h

Xbox One
Xbox Series
Log in or Register to track Super Mega Baseball 2 achievements progress.
Keep 'em Guessing

Keep 'em Guessing

Throw at least one pitch of each pitch type in a single game.

10

1.32%

How to unlock the Keep 'em Guessing achievement in Super Mega Baseball 2 - Definitive Guide

It seems you must do this against the computer; no 2-controller game. I did this in an Exhibition game, but Season games should be good also. Any game length will do. I'm guessing it can be done in Season and Elimination games also. I tried it in a Custom game and it didn't pop for me. But Otouto72 says
If anyone else gets it in a custom game, let me know.

There are 8 total pitches you need to use in ONE game.
Since one pitcher can't have all 8 pitches in their repertoire, you'll need to use relief pitchers to complete the list.

Teams with the pitchers who have all 8 among them:
HERBISAURS
SP - Dick Lukas - 4F, CB, SL, CH, FK
RP - Leonar Ramiro - 2F, CF
RP - Grump Everbright - SB
SIRLOINS (Thanks Zoot Marlowe)
SP - Slip Vanderwink - 4F, CH, FK, CB, SL 
SP - Bugsy Snugs - CF, 2F
SP - Kerwin Arches - SB
All 3 are starters so if you plan on playing the whole game use whomever you want to pitch the most innings last.
OVERDOGS (Thanks Firebird22x)
SP - Larry La'Joy - 4F, CH, CB, SL, SB
SP - Chasey Kim - 2F, FK
SP - Terrok Smith - CF
All 3 are starters
WIDELOADS (Thanks HighBoltage08)
SP - Chugg Burbony - 4F, 2F, CF, SL, CH 
Latoya Lumberg - CB, FK
Bale Bozzer - SB
Make one of these teams the Home team and play as them, so you pitch first. Then just pitch one of each type, then substitute the next pitcher, then pitch their new types, then substitute the 3rd and use their new types. This can be done all in one inning. To prevent the inning from ending too soon, don't throw hitters out if they hit the ball. Throwing outside the strike zone helps too. You also need to get past the first batter before you can substitute pitchers. Achievement pops soon after your 8th unique pitch is made.

To substitute, press cn_Y. Highlight the pitcher and press cn_X. Select next pitcher and press cn_A. Then press cn_B to resume game.
I'll add teams if anyone else finds more.
68
2

02 May 2018 03:03

19 Comments
You can just throw balls for each pitch, this way you don't even have to worry about them hitting the ball at all. 2 batters and the achievement is yours.
0
0
By Lil Toney87 on 02 May 2018 14:59
That's why this sentence was already in the text:
Throwing outside the strike zone helps too.

Thanks!
0
0
By TheDude722 on 02 May 2018 22:04
Sweet. I'll add the info. Thanks!
0
0
By TheDude722 on 02 May 2018 22:38
This can be done with the Overdogs as well:
Larry La'Joy - 4F, CH, CB, SL, SB,
Chasey Kim - 2F, FK
Terrok Smith for CF.

These three are all starters.
0
0
By Firebird22x on 03 May 2018 02:41
Thanks!
0
0
By TheDude722 on 03 May 2018 08:19
Can be done with Wideloads as well:
Chugg Burbony 4F, 2F, CF, SL, CH
Latoya Lumberg CB, FK
Bale Bozzer SB
0
0
By ToastMan227 on 03 May 2018 21:33
Thanks! I'll add it.
0
0
By TheDude722 on 03 May 2018 21:41
Does it have to be a 9 inning game? will it pop as soon as you hit the 8th pitch type in the game or once the game is over?
0
0
By iiTs Hawk on 03 May 2018 22:20
On the 8th unique pitch... guess I'll add that too...
0
0
By TheDude722 on 03 May 2018 23:26
Tried this 3 times in a 2-controller game while doing the 2 error inning achievement and it didn't work, so you might want to add that it has to be against the CPU. Popped immediately first time I did it against the computer.
0
0
By erod550 on 04 May 2018 00:55
Erod550 is right doing it with 2 controllers won't work as I tried it 3 times also and it didn't work for me. It has to be vs the CPU
0
0
By Supastar1980 on 04 May 2018 01:06
Added at the top. Thanks.
0
0
By TheDude722 on 04 May 2018 01:44
I've just played a 9 innings game, used all the pitchers and used all of their individual pitches and this didn't unlock!

Is it that I'm playing with the Moose team?
0
0
By Iron Man TStark on 13 May 2018 11:14
Try using one of the 4 listed teams above. Not all teams' pitchers cover the required pitches.
0
0
By TheDude722 on 13 May 2018 12:23
I just did this in a custom season game with two custom teams, Union (Ungulates) and Sharks (Sawteeth). I assumed that I had done this and I didn't get it meaning it doesn't unlock in a custom game, however upon further inspection I discovered that no-one in the Union team had a screwball, so I gave it to one of my relief pitchers and rotated the three pitchers that had the pitch types throughout the game and presto!
0
0
By Otouto72 on 18 Jun 2018 15:28
Just got it. Threw everything in the dirt to ensure nobody got a swing so I wouldn't lose count. Immediately after my 2nd reliever threw the 8th pitch in the dirt, the achieve popped.
0
0
By Osmagic17 on 06 May 2020 03:11
Nice... if your name is O's Magic, are you an Orioles fan? or does that mean something else?
0
0
By TheDude722 on 06 May 2020 04:20
Can also be done with The Sirloins using Slip Vanderwink 4F - CH - FK - CB - SL
Bugsy Snugs CF - 2F and Kerwin Arches for SB. All 3 are starters so if you plan on playing the whole game use whomever you want to pitch the most innings last.
0
0
By Kenshin Akusai on 02 May 2018 22:31
So weird, this achievement never actually popped for me. I got it, but I had to check the "Unlocked" list. I tried this like three times before checking thinking I must be doing something wrong. Anyway, great guide - thanks for the help!
0
0
By KiRRAYNE on 12 Jun 2018 19:52
View all 19 comments Show less comments
It seems you must do this against the computer; no 2-controller game. I did this in an Exhibition game. Any game length will do. I'm guessing it can be done in Season and Elimination games also. I tried it in a Custom game but it didn't pop for me. If anyone else gets it in a custom game, let me know.

There are 8 total pitches you need to use in ONE game.
Since one pitcher can't have all 8 pitches in their repertoire, you'll need to use relief pitchers to complete the list.

Teams with the pitchers who have all 8 among them:
HERBISAURS
SP - Dick Lukas - 4F, CB, SL, CH, FK
RP - Leonar Ramiro - 2F, CF
RP - Grump Everbright - SB
SIRLOINS (Thanks https://www.trueachievements.com/gamer/Zoot+Marlowe)
SP - Slip Vanderwink - 4F, CH, FK, CB, SL 
SP - Bugsy Snugs - CF, 2F
SP - Kerwin Arches - SB
All 3 are starters so if you plan on playing the whole game use whomever you want to pitch the most innings last.
OVERDOGS (Thanks https://www.trueachievements.com/gamer/Firebird22x)
SP - Larry La'Joy - 4F, CH, CB, SL, SB
SP - Chasey Kim - 2F, FK
SP - Terrok Smith - CF
All 3 are starters
WIDELOADS (Thanks https://www.trueachievements.com/gamer/HighBoltage08)
SP - Chugg Burbony - 4F, 2F, CF, SL, CH 
Latoya Lumberg - CB, FK
Bale Bozzer - SB
Make one of these teams the Home team and play as them, so you pitch first. Then just pitch one of each type, then substitute the next pitcher, then pitch their new types, then substitute the 3rd and use their new types. This can be done all in one inning. To prevent the inning from ending too soon, don't throw hitters out if they hit the ball. Throwing outside the strike zone helps too. You also need to get past the first batter before you can substitute pitchers. Trophy pops soon after your 8th unique pitch is made.

To substitute, press cn_T. Highlight the pitcher and press cn_S. Select next pitcher and press cn_X. Then press cn_O to resume game.
I'll add teams if anyone else finds more.
0
0

25 May 2018 19:22