Tell Me Why

Missable achievement.

Shortly after you unlock the story-related "Are You My Daddy" achievement, you will switch to playing as Tyler. After a bit of talking, you will go ice fishing with Michael.

To unlock the achievement, you must catch THREE fish while talking to him. It is done via a very easy mini game of holding down the Left Trigger to keep a cursor within a sweet spot, and then simply holding down Right Trigger. You'll have to switch between these buttons about three times each mini game.

After catching the third fish this will unlock. If you happen to miss a fish, you can replay via chapter select.

During the mission chosen family, you will be ice fishing with Michael! Each time you can catch a fish there will be a prompt to click the A button then you will play a little mini game to reel it in! Just make sure you catch all 3 fish and you'll get the achievement!

This achievement is pretty hard to miss, but if your still confused here is a video guide with all the chapter 3 related achievements and collectibles! The Fish All The Fish Achievement Starts at 3:03! Timestamps for the other achievements and collectibles are in the description!

Here is my 100% Achievement guide and full walkthrough!

After the scene with Sam in his garage, you now play as Tyler who has indeed gone ice fishing with big mike.
Be prepared for a lot of and long bit of conversation here.

So we need to catch all 3 fish, and the 1st one is like a tutorial for us.

Press and hold until you get to the (green?) Part in the middle..
You need to keep your cursor here until it changes and then you must press and hold the button.
It will swap back and forth only a few short times but it is very easy.

Also note, keep an eye on your fishing gear as when you see it move you only have a few seconds to click on it before it goes away. (Wether more show up or not I'm sure but best to be safe than sorry)

Go to 1:02:25 in my video if you prefer to see how it is done


Hope this helps!

In the chapter 'Chosen Family', you will be fishing with Michael on the frozen lake. You will be having a conversation throughout this entire time. Make sure to pay attention to the fishing rod as you will be given a timed prompt to catch a fish. You will only have three opportunities, so you can't miss one. Once fishing, you just need to hold the left trigger into the sweet spot and then hold the right trigger to reel in the fish. You can replay any section of the Episode in Isolation mode without overwriting your story progress.