The Dark Pictures Anthology: The Devil In Me

To get all the trophies, in fact, you only need to complete the game 1 time (single player normal mode), with the plan to get “Everyone Survived” (Good Ending) and “Best Ending” with saving the dog (both are obtained at the same time). It is better to collect all the pictures (all) and secrets at once (48 out of 50, 2 can only be obtained by replaying the Curators Cut in the Party chapter). “No One Survived” is knocked out simply by replaying the very last chapter on the boat. Here it is better to get “Guilty” by beating the Lighthouse.

Next, replay the game from the chapter with the vacuum chamber to get the ending “Worthy of a Reward” and “The Cycle Continues” (Only Kate and Clark must be alive at the Lighthouse. Also note, this is impossible to do in the Curators Cut, since you will not have control for Kate at the right moment!), since it is impossible to kill Erin after this chapter, even by skipping all the QTEs. She will live to reach the lighthouse and the two trophies associated with this ending will be ruined. Here we also make the “Exhale” trophy, picking up a screwdriver in front of the trap with glass (one of the items necessary for platinum) to kill Jamie; there is no point in knocking him out on the first playthrough.

Then we start the game again in the Curators Cut version to receive the trophies “Collect all items” and “Take all photographs for Karl” (Forensic Photographer). You only need to play until the Spa chapter, since all additional photographs end there (provided that you took possible photographs in previous playthroughs).