The Innsmouth Case
23 Achievements
1,000
1-2h
PC
Xbox One
Xbox Series
Hard Truths
Traumatized Evelyn Details for this achievement will be revealed once unlocked
10
27.43%
How to unlock the Hard Truths achievement in The Innsmouth Case - Definitive Guide
themindisacity
Be on great terms with Dahlia by the time you get to dinner (i.e. be playing a game where you've unlocked One Night Stand 
). Sleep with her at dinner, propose to her (I did this in the attic, but it's probably fine if you do it at the dinner table), agree to sacrifice, but throw the dagger away. When you leave the cave, tell Evelyn the truth: that she is likely the result of a union between a woman and a fish.
). Sleep with her at dinner, propose to her (I did this in the attic, but it's probably fine if you do it at the dinner table), agree to sacrifice, but throw the dagger away. When you leave the cave, tell Evelyn the truth: that she is likely the result of a union between a woman and a fish.