The Magic Circle: Gold Edition

If you want to avoid two playthroughs, do not choose to press the button the first time. Allow him to finish his rant unlocking this achievement. At that point dashboard, quit the game and reload. The game will take you back to the start of the E4.

This achievement is obtained during go into his long speech. If you listen to the whole thing and do not skip until he is completely done ranting you will be awarded with 'Starfather.'

Opposite side of the spectrum, skipping his rant at any time will net you with


(Two playthroughs are required to obtain both achievements)