Time on Frog Island
36 Achievements
7-9h
PS5
What?!
Ask a frog about the same item 3 times in a row
60.0%
How to unlock the What?! achievement in Time on Frog Island - Definitive Guide
Bonkekook
TrueAchievements
TrueAchievements
This achievement is for talking to a frog about an item 3 times in a row. I recommend taking care of this right off the bat when you start your playthrough, as I do in the video below.
All you have to do is grab an item a Frog won't understand and talk to the frog 3 times in a row while carrying it. In-between talking to the frog once, run away, drop the item, pick it back up and talk to them again. I found you may throw the item instead of talking to the Frog the second and third time, so running away and dropping the item stops that from happening.
Just about any item will do, as long as it isn't related to a Quest the Frog has for you. I use the bottle lying on the beach next to us at the beginning of the game.
You can see this in action starting at 17:22 in the video below.
All you have to do is grab an item a Frog won't understand and talk to the frog 3 times in a row while carrying it. In-between talking to the frog once, run away, drop the item, pick it back up and talk to them again. I found you may throw the item instead of talking to the Frog the second and third time, so running away and dropping the item stops that from happening.
Just about any item will do, as long as it isn't related to a Quest the Frog has for you. I use the bottle lying on the beach next to us at the beginning of the game.
You can see this in action starting at 17:22 in the video below.
Velvet
When you talk to another frog while carrying something they don't want, they'll respond to you with a confused "?". Speak to any frog with the same item 3 times (and get that "?" each time) to unlock this trophy.
