Virginia
17 Achievements
1,000
3-4h
Lemon
Susan's checked between the booths and under the counter, but where she left it is anyone's guess
49
24.53%
How to unlock the Lemon achievement in Virginia - Definitive Guide
This applies to several of the other achievements as well. The achievements for this game are all pretty unique in that the thing you need to do to get the achievement generally happens earlier, but you don't get the achievement until you actually see the effect later on.
Missable
Once you arrive at the roadhouse, interact with Halperin and move to the next room. In the bar, there will lay a white-red towel on the right, next to the entrance. Pick it up. At a later point in the game you'll have to look at Susan, who works at the diner, wearing the towel as a bandana. You might miss looking at here, but near the end will be a scene in the diner where you have full control.
If you haven't unlocked it by that point, don't interact with the baby, instead keep looking at Susan's bandana until the trophy unlocks. In case you forgot to pick up the towel and just want to go for this trophy, you'll have to play at least from Chapter 18 (Roadhouse) to Chapter 21 (Photograph).
This achievement is in two parts. If you miss this in your initial playthough, after you’ve completed the game, reload Chapter 18, ‘Roadhouse’ and play through until the achievement unlocks in Chapter 21, ‘Photograph.’
Play through the game until you arrive at the bar ‘Sojourner’s Truth’. Once in the outside hallway, interact with Halperin and she will give you a ring. When you walk through the doors, instead of walking straight, turn to your right and sitting on a counter will be a red/white bandana. Pick it up by pressing .
Play through until ‘Friday’ pops up on the screen. The next scene you will be back in the diner. Immediately look to your right at the waitress (Susan) who is wearing the bandana. Keep looking at her until the achievement unlocks. Make sure you do this quickly as you only have a limited amount of time.