Virtual Villagers Origins 2

First off upgrade your crafting to level 2.

The resources you need to gather for this are Lava, Water x2, and Wheat.

To make the dough you will need to craft the following, all made in the crafting hut:

First combine Lava and Water to make Stone, then combine the Stone with the Wheat to make Flour. Once the Flour is finished, combine that with another water to create the Dough, after that drag a villager to the hut and select the Dough. The villager will then bring the Dough to the table and place it there, where it will be ready to make into a pie for the Master Chef achievement.