We Were Here Forever

After following the linear path, you’ll reach a courtyard with a giant owl statue ahead. From the entry gate, to the left is a stage and to the right is a mechanism and a smaller owl statue. Player 1 waits at the stage, Player 2 interacts with the small owl and gets spun inside the wall. Player 2 is in a room with many heads and must pass certain heads through the mechanism to Player 1 who can place them on the stage dummies.

I’ve tried 3 times and the story was the same every time so I’m going to share my experience.

A body in a chair and a body kneeling beside is King Bartholomeus and the Jester. Player 2 passes those heads for Player 1 to place.
A body standing at a door and a body kneeling at a stone wall are Alard Clockenmaker and Yde Steenhouwere is laying the stone.
Yaebrant Bronsghieter studies the schematic on the board and Hylle gazes at the stars.
Princess Emilia sneaks behind a guard and Princess Katherine steals a book from a safe.

If the story is not the same for you, there are books around the room that tell the identity of each person’s head. Each story will have a hint in the text about the person’s action on stage. Sending the head tells Player 1 a story and they can get more detail to complete the riddle.

Player 2 will get this achievement, Player 1 will get “Capitulum Carnival”. To get the opposite achievement, you must quit to the main menu, load the checkpoint in chapter 2 and swap roles. I recommend completing the playthrough first so to not glitch any achievements.

If the riddle is different for you, let me know and I will remove my method of getting it completed so others will not be confused why my game is not the same as their game. Thanks!