WWE 2K19

It’s very easy. Just start a match with you as the champion and the A.I. as the challenger make sure the superstar who is the champion has the Power to the Punch Payback. I chosed Baron Corbin and gave him a random title to hold and have him defend it. Now start your title match against the challenger and let him attack you to build up your Payback meter then just use it on him. Note: he can reverse it so beware if the A.I. stops you. Hit him with the brass knuckles and get DQ and you’ll get the achievement. Happy achievement Hunting ;)

Play a champion Vs challenger (AI-Play only with DQ on) you being the champion selecting the power of the punch payback trait. Get beaten up to fill up the trait. Make sure your reverse to stand up and press Y to execute the power of the punch within the depleting payback meter. Watch out for reveals by AI.

Choose One on One normal match, then pick any wrestler you want, editing out the minor (yellow) Payback and choosing the Power of the Punch Payback (red). Now choose any opponent, and then click and choose a title to be on the line. Let him rough you up until you have your payback charged up, then reverse a move and hold and press , and then when he's in position to get the achievement.