WWE 2K23

This achievement comes during the third part of the Legacy story (The Champ(s) Is Here!). The specific mission is "Elevate Your Status". You can see where you're up to via the Story Progress menu. You will be defending your tag titles against Shayna and Ronda at the Day 1 event. Follow the objectives (damage Shayna, and then tag your partner in) and then you'll be given a choice to help or betray your partner. This achievement is for betraying her and leaving her to tap out.

Obviously, you cannot get both of these achievements in one playthrough, however if you don't want to reply the whole story follow these steps to get them both on one save.

Once you get up to the Day 1 event, quit the game completely, making sure it's saved and your save is backed up to the cloud. I'm not sure how to ensure this but I'd just wait a little while to make sure it is. Start the game back up and follow the objectives and complete the match with one of your choices. After the cutscene and you press "continue" the achievement will pop immediately. Press the guide button, go down to WWE 2K23, press start, manage game and add-ons, go down to saved data, press A on your user profiles data, and then "delete from console" do NOT delete everywhere. After you've done this, click back on the game and it should load to the main menu. When you get back into the Legacy save, you should be back at the start of the Day 1 event. Complete the objectives again and choose the opposite choice, and you'll pop the other achievement.