Tell Me Why

This is an alternate ending and thus missable.



Side note: I did this on my 2nd playthrough of the chapter while going for the "Life Tears Us Apart" Achievement. This may or may not make a difference, but I believe it shouldn't.

Currently it is still unclear what exactly is needed but so far it turns out that you have to choose mostly positive, tell Eddy the truth in Chapter 3 and choose at the end Tom's memory. I recommend to do this achievement together with the
on your first playthrough. You need 2 playthroughs to get all achievements. There is no indicator in the game how many positive choices you needed, so for the safe side I recommend be positive as possible.

Here is a list of all my positive choices during my playthrough. The remaining choices should not be any effect to any achievement in the game (as example Tessa at Graveyard)

Chapter 1
Ferry
- Fine
Ronan House - Outside before you get inside heads to the docks, on the right side is a bench on the way
- choose both options then leave
Ronan House - Puzzle Door
- Solve the puzzle correctly (Moose - Bear - Pelican)
Ronan House - Balcony
- Maybe Tessa has answers
- Is something wrong
- That book changed everything
- Wasn't ready to come back
- I was hiding from everyone
Store
- Choose Tyler's memory
Store - Talk with Tessa (after you find all clues)
- We remembered details
- October 2004
- You told het about the camp
- The Virtue Seekers Youth Camp
Police station
- Being kept apart was wrong

Chapter 2
Ronan House - Outside
- Choose Tylers's memory
Car Stop (Telephone conversation with the realtor)
- It's not the right time
Police station (After Archive Room)
- Let's talk in private
- So Tessa came to you?
- Just like that, huh?
- We could get there with time
Store (After the plushie Battle)
- If you choose "You're swell too" it is negative, the other one leads into nothing
Graveyard - Totem
- Choose Alyson's memory
Ronan House - Docks
- Just one more time

Chapter 3
Eddy's House - Talk with Michael
- Tell Michael about the Memories
- That could work
Police station
- That's not true
- I killed Mary-Ann
Fishing with Michael
- I pushed her too hard
- I didn't really think about that
Ronan House - Barn
- Solve all three puzzles correctly and open the box with the code after that
Ronan House - Dock
- Choose Tom's memory (Mary-Ann did not threaten Tyler)

If you need a visual guide I have create a 100% video guide for this game with all achievements, all collectibles and all choices.

Chapter 1

Chapter 2

Chapter 3

Second Playthrough

Se non l'hai ricevuto durante la tua prima partita, scegli Capitoli -> Riproduci -> Capitolo 3 Veni, Vidi, Vecchi -> "Riproduci l'avanzamento da questa scena".

(La scelta della modalità Isolamento non proseguirà con la sezione successiva con il finale diverso.)

Alla fine di questa sequenza, sul pontile, scegli l'opzione:
"Credi alla versione di Tom,
Mary-Ann non ha minacciato Tyler"

Questo ti porterà a un finale alternativo, nei panni Tyler.
Quando hai finito di parlare al telefono con Alyson entra in casa e interagisci con il laptop tra il divano e la scala nel soggiorno, uscite dalla visuale del laptop e prendetelo, prendete anche le foto sul bancone della cucina.
Interagisci con la porta d'ingresso "LASCIA LA CASA PER SEMPRE"
Al termine del video si sbloccherà l'obiettivo.